印度人口和中国相近,未来印度经济会超过中国吗?
2021-12-12 地平线123 28148
正文翻译


印度人口和中国相近,未来印度经济会超过中国吗?

原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处


评论翻译
Anchal Tamrakar, B.A from Political Science (2023)
Economy of Germany is 3.95 lakh crores USD (2018) , purchasing power of every individual 47,603.03 USD (2018) population = 8crore

德国2018年的经济规模是3.95万亿美元,德国人口8千万人均购买力是47603美元

Economy of india 2.72 lakh crores USD (2018) 1 USD = 78₹ ,1EURO= 83₹ purchasing power of individual 1000usd population 135 crore

印度2018年的经济规模是2.72万亿美元,1美元=78卢比,1欧元=83卢比,13.5亿印度人的人均购买力只有1000美元
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处


8 crore population can be able to generate gdp of 3.95 lakh crore
135 crore population can only able to generate gdp of 2.72 lakhs..
It's always QUALITY wins over QUANTITY

8千万人口的德国能创造3.95万亿美元的GDP
13.5亿人口的印度创造的GDP却只有2.72万亿美元
质量永远比数量重要

Mithun S
Your comparison is wrong, you cannot compare growing economy with a already grown economy!
India has the potential to grow double digit whereas economies like US, Germany, UK only grow ~2% every year on an Average.
India can catch up and has all the possibilities to overtake!

你这样比较是不对的,你不能把发展中经济体和发达经济体进行比较。印度具备两位数增长的潜力,但像美国德国英国这样的国家每年平均只能增长大约2%左右。
印度可以追上并完全有可能将其超越。

Anchal Tamrakar
India can , but when?????????????????
This is Germany destroyed by allied force 1947 it's totally destroyed india was in much better condition..
This is Japan..
Nuclear attack by lord USA…
But what happen to fruitful india..

印度可以超越他们,但印度什么时候才能做到呢?
这是1947年德国被盟军破坏的样子,当时的德国被完全摧毁,印度的情况要比德国好得多
这是遭到美国核攻击的日本
但富饶的印度又发生了什么?

Vinay Yadav
Major problem is corrupt, illiterate politicians and useless government policies. We will never become developed country if same situations remain prent.
People don't have any option. They have to choose between corrupt politicians. Almost all of them are corrupt and have committed serious crimes. It is like we have to choose the least corrupt among them.

主要的问题在于腐败,不学无术的政客和没有任何作用的政府政策。如果情况一直这样下去的话,那么我们永远也无法成为发达国家。人们别无选择,他们只能在腐败的领导人之间进行选择,几乎所有领导人都很腐败,都犯有严重的罪行,这就好像是要在一群腐败分子当中选择一个不那么腐败的人出来一样。

Aaryan Shrestha
Well
I guess you didnt realize India's gdp went from 240 billion usd in 1990 to 3.2 trillion dollars in 2020
Yeah we have been a bit slow but well even China was only 2 trillion in 2006
Even by conservative estimates in spite of covid
India will be a 6 trillion usd economy by 2028

我想你还没有意识到印度的GDP已经从1990年的2400亿美元上升到2020年的3.2万亿美元了。
是的我们发展的速度是有点慢,但中国的GDP在2006年的时候也只有2万亿美元。尽管有新冠疫情但按照保守估计,印度GDP到2028年将达到6万亿美元级别。

Aryan Vyas
UK, Germany have only 6 Crore population, and their population is stable, so enough jobs even if growth is 0 %. Due to poor GDP most Indians are unemployed nowadays. ALso these countries are developed having huge advantage.

英国德国的人口只有六千万,他们的人口非常稳定,所以即便增长率是0%,他们也可以提供足够的就业岗位。由于糟糕的经济形势,现在大量的印度人处于失业状态。而且这些都是发达国家,拥有巨大的优势。

Pushparaj Naik
In your dream ….nationalistic answer doesn't help

在你的梦里或许可以实现,民族主义式的回答没有任何帮助

Kaushik Saha
So much potential!!
When will it become kinetic, please?

印度有那么大的潜力。但请问印度的潜力什么时候才能发挥作用呢?

ShaanChowdhary
To become like China India will need atleast 50 years as chinas Economy is 5 times larger than India.
But in those 50 years china might surpass America, so eventually we cannot surpass Economy of China.

印度要想赶上中国,至少需要50年的时间,因为中国的GDP是印度的五倍多
但未来五十年中国或许会超越美国,所以最终我们的经济还是无法超越中国

Ganapati Subramani
India's current GDP is where China was in 2005–06. They opened up around 15–20 years before India did. I don't see an issue with India's GDP growing along the same trajectory.
The real challenge for both is per capita GDP reaching the level of advanced economies.

印度目前的GDP相当于中国2005年到2006年的水平。中国的改革开放比印度早15到20年。印度的GDP和中国沿着同样的轨迹在增长,所以我不认为印度的GDP有什么问题。达到发达经济体人均GDP水平才是中印两国真正的挑战

ShaanChowdhary
The real difference in GDP or per capita GDP is huge between the two economies, may be as per your opinion in 15 to 20 years we managed to get to what they are now but by then china may be close to American GDP.

中印两国经济体在GDP或人均GDP上的差异是巨大的,或许如你所想15到20年后我们能达到中国现在的水平,但到了那时中国的GDP或许已经接近美国了。

The real problem here is we are an Agriculture + Service based Economy and dependent on other economies including china even for basic things like Cell Phone or children's Toys.
We are basically consumers (Importers) and they are producers (exporters). Eg - We need to use Samsung's 5g tech and they have their own 5g tech. We import 4.5 gen fighter planes they have similar indigenous fighter planes.

真正的问题在于我们的经济要依赖于农业和服务业,我们甚至连手机和儿童玩具这样的基本用品都要依赖包括中国在内的其他经济体。
我们基本上是消费者(进口商),他们是生产者(出口商)。我们需要使用三星的5G技术,中国有自己的5G技术,我们要进口4.5代战机,而中国本土就可以自己制造出类似的战机。

Wahab Mohmadsharif
Wow, its so depressing to know we will never become a developed nation in our life time.

知道在有生之年印度都无法成为发达国家真是让我感到沮丧。

Harikrishnan Arinalloor
India,China,America has a larger potential than Germany because they have greater resources

印度中国和美国比德国有更大的潜力,因为他们拥有更多的资源。
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处


Balachandran Krishnamoorty, former Cost and Management Accountant at Self-Employment
Population numbers do not determine an economy. The quality of the population does. Surpassing China's economy is not going to be possible.

人口规模无法决定经济发展。决定经济发展的是人口质量。超越中国经济几乎是不可能的事情。

Sitaram Kantheti, former Chief Manager Retired
Sir
I do not understand how people compare china and india. Except population there is no comparison between them.

我不明白为什么人们要把中国和印度放在一起比较。除了人口规模外,这两个国家没有任何可比性。

收藏译文