QA问答：为什么印度的程序员，要批评像Whitehat这样的印度创造的应用？难道他们不希望用这种方法，让印度取得进步，并且帮助孩子们学习吗？
正文翻译
Why are Indian programmers criticizing Indian made apps like Whitehat? Don't they want India to make progress and help kids learn in the process?
为什么印度的程序员，要批评像Whitehat这样的印度创造的应用？难道他们不希望用这种方法，让印度取得进步，并且帮助孩子们学习吗？
为什么印度的程序员，要批评像Whitehat这样的印度创造的应用？难道他们不希望用这种方法，让印度取得进步，并且帮助孩子们学习吗？
评论翻译
If this indeed is an Indian Product - then it is a Worthy Product designed by an Indian named Santosh Hulawale. Yet how many have heard of him? Very few. It has been praised by Walter Mitchell of Robotics Global.
Meanwhile - you have the world of praise for ‘Other Popular Products’ which are perhaps 50% of the above Humanoid but 500% more hyped.
Imagine a Kid in a Village - scoring 71% marks in his subjects. He is the Topper of the school. The Hero.
如果确实要说一款印度产品，那么他就是由一位名叫Santosh Hulawale的印度人设计的有价值的产品。然而，有多少人听说过他？很少。他得到过Robotics Global平台的 Walter Mitchell的称赞。
与此同时，“其他流行产品”可能是上述人形产品的50%，但宣传力度却高出了500%。
想象一下，一个村庄里的孩子——他的科目得分为71%。他是学校的前几名。英雄。
Image Copied from Mr Duraiswamy who also posted this Answer on Quora.
Is this an Aladdin Story? Even Suryavansam or Annamalai had better rags to riches stories than this.
图片来自Duraiswamy先生，他也在Quora上发布了这个答案。
这是阿拉丁故事吗？就连Suryavansam或Annamalai都有比这更好的白手起家故事。
Kanthaswamy Balasubramaniam
How do you want India to make Progress and How do you help kids learn?
The present way is simply to praise Mediocre Apps or Mediocre Products created by Indians to the skies and have Kids learn Oracle and Python and Java before they are 10 years old or have the kids play a glorified version of Candy Crush by paying Rs. 1 Lakh for the course.
How do either of these things Help you make Progress?
你希望如何让印度取得进步？你要怎么帮助孩子们学习？
目前的方法就是简单的把印度人创作的平庸应用程序或平庸产品捧上天，让孩子们在10岁之前学习 Oracle 、Python和Java，或者让孩子们通过支付10万卢比的课程费，去玩一款吹嘘版的《糖果粉碎传奇》。
这两件事如何帮助你取得进步？
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
How do you want India to make Progress and How do you help kids learn?
The present way is simply to praise Mediocre Apps or Mediocre Products created by Indians to the skies and have Kids learn Oracle and Python and Java before they are 10 years old or have the kids play a glorified version of Candy Crush by paying Rs. 1 Lakh for the course.
How do either of these things Help you make Progress?
你希望如何让印度取得进步？你要怎么帮助孩子们学习？
目前的方法就是简单的把印度人创作的平庸应用程序或平庸产品捧上天，让孩子们在10岁之前学习 Oracle 、Python和Java，或者让孩子们通过支付10万卢比的课程费，去玩一款吹嘘版的《糖果粉碎传奇》。
这两件事如何帮助你取得进步？
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
If this indeed is an Indian Product - then it is a Worthy Product designed by an Indian named Santosh Hulawale. Yet how many have heard of him? Very few. It has been praised by Walter Mitchell of Robotics Global.
Meanwhile - you have the world of praise for ‘Other Popular Products’ which are perhaps 50% of the above Humanoid but 500% more hyped.
Imagine a Kid in a Village - scoring 71% marks in his subjects. He is the Topper of the school. The Hero.
如果确实要说一款印度产品，那么他就是由一位名叫Santosh Hulawale的印度人设计的有价值的产品。然而，有多少人听说过他？很少。他得到过Robotics Global平台的 Walter Mitchell的称赞。
与此同时，“其他流行产品”可能是上述人形产品的50%，但宣传力度却高出了500%。
想象一下，一个村庄里的孩子——他的科目得分为71%。他是学校的前几名。英雄。
What would you want?
Would you want the Teachers of this kid to tell him “Beta! In Delhi and Mumbai you have thousands of kids who score 100 marks, so I will give you those books and you better score well if you want to compete with them”
OR
Would you want the Teachers to tell him “Beta! You are the greatest. You are amazing. You are Cool. You are a winner!!! At least you have tried. You are the son of a poor farmer and yet you get 71%”
When the Kid competes - he will be pulverized into atoms by his competition.
你要怎么做？
你想让这个孩子的老师告诉他：“贝塔！在德里和孟买，有成千上万的孩子得了100分，所以我会把这些书给你，如果你想和他们竞争，你最好要取得更好的成绩。”
还是：
你想让老师们告诉他：“贝塔！你是最棒的。你太棒了。你很酷。你是赢家！！！至少你试过了。你是一个贫穷农民的儿子，但你得到了71%。”
当孩子参加比赛时，他会被竞争粉碎成原子。
Would you want the Teachers of this kid to tell him “Beta! In Delhi and Mumbai you have thousands of kids who score 100 marks, so I will give you those books and you better score well if you want to compete with them”
OR
Would you want the Teachers to tell him “Beta! You are the greatest. You are amazing. You are Cool. You are a winner!!! At least you have tried. You are the son of a poor farmer and yet you get 71%”
When the Kid competes - he will be pulverized into atoms by his competition.
你要怎么做？
你想让这个孩子的老师告诉他：“贝塔！在德里和孟买，有成千上万的孩子得了100分，所以我会把这些书给你，如果你想和他们竞争，你最好要取得更好的成绩。”
还是：
你想让老师们告诉他：“贝塔！你是最棒的。你太棒了。你很酷。你是赢家！！！至少你试过了。你是一个贫穷农民的儿子，但你得到了71%。”
当孩子参加比赛时，他会被竞争粉碎成原子。
Likewise
How do you get a 6 year old to become a Programmer?
Unless he is a Young Sheldon or that other girl, nobody can understand logic of programming unless they are older and understand other things.
Yet you have “Teachers” who dont know the difference between jaxcript and Java and who have no clue what OOP is - teaching coding to 6 year olds by asking them to drag and drop lines of codes to create apps which will sell for a billion dollars?
同样地
你要怎么样才能让一个6岁的孩子成为一名程序员？
除非他是年轻的Sheldon或其他女孩，否则他们跟本无法理解理解编程的逻辑，除非等他们年纪更大，懂得其他东西。
然而，你有一些“老师”，他们不知道jaxcript和Java之间的区别，也不知道OOP是什么——你让这群老师教一群6岁的孩子拖放一行行代码来创建售价10亿美元的应用程序？
How do you get a 6 year old to become a Programmer?
Unless he is a Young Sheldon or that other girl, nobody can understand logic of programming unless they are older and understand other things.
Yet you have “Teachers” who dont know the difference between jaxcript and Java and who have no clue what OOP is - teaching coding to 6 year olds by asking them to drag and drop lines of codes to create apps which will sell for a billion dollars?
同样地
你要怎么样才能让一个6岁的孩子成为一名程序员？
除非他是年轻的Sheldon或其他女孩，否则他们跟本无法理解理解编程的逻辑，除非等他们年纪更大，懂得其他东西。
然而，你有一些“老师”，他们不知道jaxcript和Java之间的区别，也不知道OOP是什么——你让这群老师教一群6岁的孩子拖放一行行代码来创建售价10亿美元的应用程序？
Image Copied from Mr Duraiswamy who also posted this Answer on Quora.
Is this an Aladdin Story? Even Suryavansam or Annamalai had better rags to riches stories than this.
图片来自Duraiswamy先生，他也在Quora上发布了这个答案。
这是阿拉丁故事吗？就连Suryavansam或Annamalai都有比这更好的白手起家故事。
You want India to progress and Kids to progress
Stop praising Mediocrity and tell the Mediocre Heroes to compete with the Best or shut up.
Let Kids enjoy themselves and let them work per their own learning rate. Their life is going to be screwed up anyway. This is after all India.
Otherwise - In 100 years it will be the same India it is today - Lies, Hype and Mediocrity.
你希望印度进步，孩子们进步，
停止赞扬平庸，告诉平庸英雄要去和最好的竞争，否则闭嘴。
让孩子们玩得开心，让他们按照自己的学习速度学习。不管怎样，他们的生活都会一团糟。这毕竟是印度。
否则——100年后，印度仍将是今天的印度——谎言、炒作和平庸。
Stop praising Mediocrity and tell the Mediocre Heroes to compete with the Best or shut up.
Let Kids enjoy themselves and let them work per their own learning rate. Their life is going to be screwed up anyway. This is after all India.
Otherwise - In 100 years it will be the same India it is today - Lies, Hype and Mediocrity.
你希望印度进步，孩子们进步，
停止赞扬平庸，告诉平庸英雄要去和最好的竞争，否则闭嘴。
让孩子们玩得开心，让他们按照自己的学习速度学习。不管怎样，他们的生活都会一团糟。这毕竟是印度。
否则——100年后，印度仍将是今天的印度——谎言、炒作和平庸。
Baskaran Ramamurthy
Everyone wants to be rich at others cost in short term, no human values, everything compromised. Stringent rules need of the hour
每个人都想在短期内以他人为代价致富，没有人性的价值观，一切都妥协了。时时刻刻需要严格的规则。
Everyone wants to be rich at others cost in short term, no human values, everything compromised. Stringent rules need of the hour
每个人都想在短期内以他人为代价致富，没有人性的价值观，一切都妥协了。时时刻刻需要严格的规则。
Rajarshi Roy
That has been the case always. There's nothing illegal in what they are doing. It's the responsibility of the parents to ensure they are spending their money well after doing some research.
一直都是这样。他们的所作所为并不违法。父母有责任在做了一些研究之后再决定，确保他们的钱花在正确的地方。
That has been the case always. There's nothing illegal in what they are doing. It's the responsibility of the parents to ensure they are spending their money well after doing some research.
一直都是这样。他们的所作所为并不违法。父母有责任在做了一些研究之后再决定，确保他们的钱花在正确的地方。
Sarvesh Prajapati
Even programming requires a immense creativity & logical ability. Till your child finishes school, he/she should have felt the delight of reading the famous classics of the world, pondered over the stars, developed interesting hobbies, enjoyed traveled few places, made good friends, learned from the subjects taught to him/her at school & should have developed reasonable sense of judgment.
If you replace all of this with programming in his/her early life, you will end up creating an automaton that is neither in touch with you, nor the world or himself/herself… an unhappy (& probably ill tempered) personality. Then the same you (parents) will blame him/her that the child didn’t end up well in the world because he/she didn’t work hard enough.
即使是编程也需要巨大的创造力和逻辑能力。在你的孩子完成学业之前，他/她应该感受到阅读经典世界著名的乐趣，望着星星思考，培养有趣的兴趣爱好，出去旅行玩得开心，结交好朋友，从学校教给他/她的科目中学习，并且发展出合理的判断力。
如果你在他/她童年的生活中，用编程来代替这一切，你最终会创造出一个既不与你亲密，也不与世界或他/她接触的机器人亲密……一个不快乐的（可能是脾气不好的）人格。同样，你（父母）也会责怪他/她，因为他/她不够努力，孩子最终没有在这个世界上取得好成绩。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Even programming requires a immense creativity & logical ability. Till your child finishes school, he/she should have felt the delight of reading the famous classics of the world, pondered over the stars, developed interesting hobbies, enjoyed traveled few places, made good friends, learned from the subjects taught to him/her at school & should have developed reasonable sense of judgment.
If you replace all of this with programming in his/her early life, you will end up creating an automaton that is neither in touch with you, nor the world or himself/herself… an unhappy (& probably ill tempered) personality. Then the same you (parents) will blame him/her that the child didn’t end up well in the world because he/she didn’t work hard enough.
即使是编程也需要巨大的创造力和逻辑能力。在你的孩子完成学业之前，他/她应该感受到阅读经典世界著名的乐趣，望着星星思考，培养有趣的兴趣爱好，出去旅行玩得开心，结交好朋友，从学校教给他/她的科目中学习，并且发展出合理的判断力。
如果你在他/她童年的生活中，用编程来代替这一切，你最终会创造出一个既不与你亲密，也不与世界或他/她接触的机器人亲密……一个不快乐的（可能是脾气不好的）人格。同样，你（父母）也会责怪他/她，因为他/她不够努力，孩子最终没有在这个世界上取得好成绩。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Avishek Sharma
The upsparing bringing enough of depression, mental stress and suicidal thoughts because your parents lost their 1L rupess and you are still a failure. Damn, the child won't even have upper understanding of Willpower to even cope with these bad thoughts.
升学带来了足够多的抑郁、精神压力和自杀念头，因为你的父母失去了1L卢比，而你仍然是一个失败者。该死，孩子甚至不会对意志力有更高的理解，甚至无法应对这些坏想法。
The upsparing bringing enough of depression, mental stress and suicidal thoughts because your parents lost their 1L rupess and you are still a failure. Damn, the child won't even have upper understanding of Willpower to even cope with these bad thoughts.
升学带来了足够多的抑郁、精神压力和自杀念头，因为你的父母失去了1L卢比，而你仍然是一个失败者。该死，孩子甚至不会对意志力有更高的理解，甚至无法应对这些坏想法。
Siddhesh Agarwal
I learnt python and I could tell you that I have spent countless days trying to debug my program, googling, fixing my errors, learning more and more, building projects etc. I could assure you that no app can teach coding to a 6–10 year old kid unti he/she wants to learn it.
Machine learning requires maths so complicated that it is beyond the understanding of many 12th standard students. It requires logic and algorithms. Do you really think that a child, who should be happily playing games on his mobile, learn all this?
我学会了python，我可以告诉你，我已经花了无数天的时间来调试我的程序，搜索，修复我的错误，学习越来越多的东西，构建项目等等。
机器学习对数学的要求如此复杂，以至于许多12年级学生无法理解。它需要逻辑和算法。你真的认为一个应该在手机上快乐玩游戏年纪的孩子，能把这所有的一切都掌握？
I learnt python and I could tell you that I have spent countless days trying to debug my program, googling, fixing my errors, learning more and more, building projects etc. I could assure you that no app can teach coding to a 6–10 year old kid unti he/she wants to learn it.
Machine learning requires maths so complicated that it is beyond the understanding of many 12th standard students. It requires logic and algorithms. Do you really think that a child, who should be happily playing games on his mobile, learn all this?
我学会了python，我可以告诉你，我已经花了无数天的时间来调试我的程序，搜索，修复我的错误，学习越来越多的东西，构建项目等等。
机器学习对数学的要求如此复杂，以至于许多12年级学生无法理解。它需要逻辑和算法。你真的认为一个应该在手机上快乐玩游戏年纪的孩子，能把这所有的一切都掌握？
Umang Kumar Singh
There are 2 ways to tell that village kid scoring 71%
You are not the only one scoring 71% .. the world is full of such toppers .. you are NOTHING .. don’t be so optimistic
You are scoring good beta.. it's commendable .. But don't stop or settle for this score.. there are certain students scoring more than this and so you should try to compete with them ..
Now you see the difference right?
Noone is stopping people from passing constructive criticism .. But some Indians just can't digest someone success.. they will just try to criticise them for every other move
And that seriosuly needs to stop!
有两种办法可以告诉村里得71%分的孩子：
1、你不是唯一一个得分71%的人……世界上到处都是这样的顶尖选手……你什么都不是……别那么乐观。
2、你的测试成绩很好……这是值得称赞的……但不要停止或满足于这个成绩……有些学生的得分超过了这个水平，所以你应该尝试与他们竞争……
现在你看到区别了吧？
没有人能阻止人们提出建设性的批评。但有些印度人就是无法消化别人的成功。他们只会尝试批评他们的每一个举动。
这真的需要停止！
There are 2 ways to tell that village kid scoring 71%
You are not the only one scoring 71% .. the world is full of such toppers .. you are NOTHING .. don’t be so optimistic
You are scoring good beta.. it's commendable .. But don't stop or settle for this score.. there are certain students scoring more than this and so you should try to compete with them ..
Now you see the difference right?
Noone is stopping people from passing constructive criticism .. But some Indians just can't digest someone success.. they will just try to criticise them for every other move
And that seriosuly needs to stop!
有两种办法可以告诉村里得71%分的孩子：
1、你不是唯一一个得分71%的人……世界上到处都是这样的顶尖选手……你什么都不是……别那么乐观。
2、你的测试成绩很好……这是值得称赞的……但不要停止或满足于这个成绩……有些学生的得分超过了这个水平，所以你应该尝试与他们竞争……
现在你看到区别了吧？
没有人能阻止人们提出建设性的批评。但有些印度人就是无法消化别人的成功。他们只会尝试批评他们的每一个举动。
这真的需要停止！
Duke Fernandez
If you were a sniper, your would have the best stats in terms of accuracy
如果你是一名狙击手，你的准确率将是最好的。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
If you were a sniper, your would have the best stats in terms of accuracy
如果你是一名狙击手，你的准确率将是最好的。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Daksh Babbar (바바 닭시)
“Teachers” who dont know the difference between jaxcript and Java and who have no clue what OOP is “
I’m pretty sure you watched that whitehat jr trial class youtube video.
“不知道jaxcript和Java之间的区别，也不知道OOP是什么的老师”
我很确定你在youtube上看了whitehat 试用班的视频。
“Teachers” who dont know the difference between jaxcript and Java and who have no clue what OOP is “
I’m pretty sure you watched that whitehat jr trial class youtube video.
“不知道jaxcript和Java之间的区别，也不知道OOP是什么的老师”
我很确定你在youtube上看了whitehat 试用班的视频。
Shivam Agrawal
It is borderline scam, it boils my blood whenever I see any of their advertisements. I am a software engineer and a software engineer can't do shit which will make him outstanding except if you are a prodigy or have a solid plan which requires experience. They are selling s false dream and they bloody well know it.
这是一个边缘骗局，每当我看到他们的每一个广告时，我都会热血沸腾。我是一名软件工程师，除非你是一名神童，或者有一个需要经验的坚实计划，否则软件工程师不能做任何让他出类拔萃的事。他们在兜售自己的虚假梦想，他们对此了如指掌。
It is borderline scam, it boils my blood whenever I see any of their advertisements. I am a software engineer and a software engineer can't do shit which will make him outstanding except if you are a prodigy or have a solid plan which requires experience. They are selling s false dream and they bloody well know it.
这是一个边缘骗局，每当我看到他们的每一个广告时，我都会热血沸腾。我是一名软件工程师，除非你是一名神童，或者有一个需要经验的坚实计划，否则软件工程师不能做任何让他出类拔萃的事。他们在兜售自己的虚假梦想，他们对此了如指掌。
Bhavesh Savla
but why would you want a 6 year old to learn computing or programing at all? If covid would not have been there, then i would never allow any 6 year old to be in front of any screen at all
但你为什么要让一个6岁的孩子学习计算机或编程呢？如果新冠肺炎没有出现，那么我绝对不会允许任何6岁的孩子出现在任何屏幕前。
but why would you want a 6 year old to learn computing or programing at all? If covid would not have been there, then i would never allow any 6 year old to be in front of any screen at all
但你为什么要让一个6岁的孩子学习计算机或编程呢？如果新冠肺炎没有出现，那么我绝对不会允许任何6岁的孩子出现在任何屏幕前。
Ajay Sinh
Any investment in health and education will benefit in the long run.
从长远来看，对卫生和教育的任何投资都将受益。
Any investment in health and education will benefit in the long run.
从长远来看，对卫生和教育的任何投资都将受益。
Ajinkya Maske
Exactly. Children should be given ample time for their cognitive development. The unrealistic expectations of parents these days are growing leaps and bounds. Everyone is in such a hurry, they want their kid to be the next big thing. And there is nothing wrong in it. But Rome was not built in a day.
There is always a process. Moreover making their children go a certain path at such an early age instead of exploring kids’ natural interest would only hamper children in the long run.
There is no end to consumerism. It is our prerogative to make the right decision which product to consume and which not to.
确实如此，应该给孩子足够的时间发展他们的认知能力。如今，父母不切实际的期望越来越高。每个人都很匆忙，他们希望自己的孩子成为下一个大人物。这并没有什么错。但冰冻三尺非一日之寒。罗马不是一天建成的。
总有一个过程。此外，让他们的孩子在这么小的时候走上一条特定的道路，而不是探索孩子的自然兴趣，从长远来看只会阻碍孩子。
消费主义永无止境。我们有权做出正确的决定，消费哪种产品，不消费哪种。
Exactly. Children should be given ample time for their cognitive development. The unrealistic expectations of parents these days are growing leaps and bounds. Everyone is in such a hurry, they want their kid to be the next big thing. And there is nothing wrong in it. But Rome was not built in a day.
There is always a process. Moreover making their children go a certain path at such an early age instead of exploring kids’ natural interest would only hamper children in the long run.
There is no end to consumerism. It is our prerogative to make the right decision which product to consume and which not to.
确实如此，应该给孩子足够的时间发展他们的认知能力。如今，父母不切实际的期望越来越高。每个人都很匆忙，他们希望自己的孩子成为下一个大人物。这并没有什么错。但冰冻三尺非一日之寒。罗马不是一天建成的。
总有一个过程。此外，让他们的孩子在这么小的时候走上一条特定的道路，而不是探索孩子的自然兴趣，从长远来看只会阻碍孩子。
消费主义永无止境。我们有权做出正确的决定，消费哪种产品，不消费哪种。
Sayan Guha
Most Indian made items have zero quality. I mean, really zero.
And WhiteHat isn't an app. It's a fraudulent and cheap company that brainwashes gullible families by targeting their kids.
In my opinion they should not be allowed to get away with it.
大多数印度制造的产品质量为零。我是说，真的是零。
WhiteHat不是一个应用程序。这是一家欺诈和廉价的公司，通过瞄准孩子来洗脑易受骗的家庭。
在我看来，不应该让他们逍遥法外。
Most Indian made items have zero quality. I mean, really zero.
And WhiteHat isn't an app. It's a fraudulent and cheap company that brainwashes gullible families by targeting their kids.
In my opinion they should not be allowed to get away with it.
大多数印度制造的产品质量为零。我是说，真的是零。
WhiteHat不是一个应用程序。这是一家欺诈和廉价的公司，通过瞄准孩子来洗脑易受骗的家庭。
在我看来，不应该让他们逍遥法外。
Ishan Khandelwal
Whitehat Jr. is nothing but a boot camp. A 6–7 year old who hasn’t even mastered English to an amateur level can’t understand computer languages. Children should not be thrown into programs like this unless they really are interested, which at their age, they can’t decide if this is something they want to spend time on. Whitehat Jr. is not actually teaching these kids anything. It’s just memorization. The teachers themselves are clueless. They have no idea what they’re actually doing. If they made something like whitehat Jr. for 14–15 year olds instead, it would actually be a great project.
The 2 big problems of whitehat jr. are —
6–10 year olds are clueless about what they’re doing.
Teachers are clueless about what they’re doing.
I’m a CS major in college and it took me 1 semester to catch up to students who have years of CS practice. Believe me when I say that you can learn everything whitehat jr. teaches a 10 year old in 3–4 years in less than 3 months as a 13–14 year old. This is no exaggeration. I would suggest to only get into computer languages when you’re older as it takes a lot of mathematics and insane logic.
Whitehat软件只是一个新兵训练营。一个6-7岁的孩子，如果英语还没有达到业余水平，他就不会理解计算机语言。除非孩子们真的感兴趣，否则他们不应该被投入到这样的项目中。在他们这个年龄，他们无法决定这是否是他们想花时间去做的事情。Whitehat软件实际上并没有教这些孩子什么。就只是简单的记忆。老师们自己也很无知。他们不知道自己在做什么。如果他们为14-15岁的孩子们制作了像Whitehat一样的东西，这实际上是一个很棒的项目。
Whitehat软件的两大问题是：
1、6-10岁的孩子对他们正在做的事情一无所知。
2、老师们对他们在做什么一无所知。
我在大学主修计算机科学，花了我一个学期的时间才赶上那些有多年计算机科学实践经验的学生。相信我，13到14岁的孩子不到3个月的时间里，就可以学会Whitehat教给一个10岁的孩子花了3-4年学会的一切。这并不夸张。我建议你长大后才开始学习计算机语言，因为这需要大量的数学和疯狂的逻辑。
Whitehat Jr. is nothing but a boot camp. A 6–7 year old who hasn’t even mastered English to an amateur level can’t understand computer languages. Children should not be thrown into programs like this unless they really are interested, which at their age, they can’t decide if this is something they want to spend time on. Whitehat Jr. is not actually teaching these kids anything. It’s just memorization. The teachers themselves are clueless. They have no idea what they’re actually doing. If they made something like whitehat Jr. for 14–15 year olds instead, it would actually be a great project.
The 2 big problems of whitehat jr. are —
6–10 year olds are clueless about what they’re doing.
Teachers are clueless about what they’re doing.
I’m a CS major in college and it took me 1 semester to catch up to students who have years of CS practice. Believe me when I say that you can learn everything whitehat jr. teaches a 10 year old in 3–4 years in less than 3 months as a 13–14 year old. This is no exaggeration. I would suggest to only get into computer languages when you’re older as it takes a lot of mathematics and insane logic.
Whitehat软件只是一个新兵训练营。一个6-7岁的孩子，如果英语还没有达到业余水平，他就不会理解计算机语言。除非孩子们真的感兴趣，否则他们不应该被投入到这样的项目中。在他们这个年龄，他们无法决定这是否是他们想花时间去做的事情。Whitehat软件实际上并没有教这些孩子什么。就只是简单的记忆。老师们自己也很无知。他们不知道自己在做什么。如果他们为14-15岁的孩子们制作了像Whitehat一样的东西，这实际上是一个很棒的项目。
Whitehat软件的两大问题是：
1、6-10岁的孩子对他们正在做的事情一无所知。
2、老师们对他们在做什么一无所知。
我在大学主修计算机科学，花了我一个学期的时间才赶上那些有多年计算机科学实践经验的学生。相信我，13到14岁的孩子不到3个月的时间里，就可以学会Whitehat教给一个10岁的孩子花了3-4年学会的一切。这并不夸张。我建议你长大后才开始学习计算机语言，因为这需要大量的数学和疯狂的逻辑。
Tarun Goyal
I don’t like your style of writing. It is too direct and borderline offensive. Still every time I read your answer I can’t help but upvote it. Because you always hit the nail.
“Stop praising Mediocrity and tell the Mediocre Heroes to compete with the Best or shut up.”
我不喜欢你的写作风格。这是一种过于直接和边缘化的进攻。但每次我读到你的答案时，我还是忍不住投赞成票。因为你总是一针见血。
“停止赞扬平庸，告诉平庸英雄要去和最好的竞争，否则闭嘴。”
I don’t like your style of writing. It is too direct and borderline offensive. Still every time I read your answer I can’t help but upvote it. Because you always hit the nail.
“Stop praising Mediocrity and tell the Mediocre Heroes to compete with the Best or shut up.”
我不喜欢你的写作风格。这是一种过于直接和边缘化的进攻。但每次我读到你的答案时，我还是忍不住投赞成票。因为你总是一针见血。
“停止赞扬平庸，告诉平庸英雄要去和最好的竞争，否则闭嘴。”
Rajeev Verma
Well, that drag and drop is called “Scratch”, and is created and taught in MIT to teach programming. And the “mediocre” minds of those against the idea of teaching kids to code(saying that a 10 year old cannot do that) don't understand the fact programming is nothing but problem solving. It's akin to saying to that a 10 year old cannot learn guitar, piano, chess, etc. just because they are small. To make coding an intellectual avenue for the olds is just a statement to satisfy the ego of these mediocre minds. Don't children learn language, or music? What makes you think they cannot learn coding. Coding is not about competing in Codechef(as most of these people do to get jobs), it's pattern matching and problem solving which is an integral part of growing up and intellectual development. I find the whole argument against the idea of kids doing coding so abhorrent. Having said that, I don't agree with Whitehat's promotional tactics. But hey, can you really blame them when a majority of India's population is motivated by financial prospects? I can count a great chunk of people who started doing coding just to get high-paying job.
好吧，这种拖放被称为“抓取”，是在麻省理工学院创建并用来教授编程的。那些反对教孩子们学习编程，说一个10岁的孩子不能这么做的“平庸”之人，并不能理解，事实编程什么都不是，重点是学会解决问题的方法。这就好比说一个10岁的孩子不能学习吉他、钢琴、国际象棋等，因为他们很小。
让编码成为年龄较大的人的智力游戏，只是为了满足这些平庸头脑自我的一种说法。孩子们不学习语言或音乐吗？是什么让你认为他们无法学习编码。学习编码不是要让他们像大多数人一样去Codechef（程序员刷题网站）上去竞争，而是学会模式匹配和问题解决，这是成长和智力发展不可或缺的一部分。
我觉得反对孩子们做编码的整个论点是如此令人憎恶。话虽如此，我不同意Whitehat的促销策略。但嘿，当印度大多数人口都被金融前景所驱动时，你真的能责怪他们吗？我可以统计出很多人开始做代码只是为了得到一份高薪工作。
Well, that drag and drop is called “Scratch”, and is created and taught in MIT to teach programming. And the “mediocre” minds of those against the idea of teaching kids to code(saying that a 10 year old cannot do that) don't understand the fact programming is nothing but problem solving. It's akin to saying to that a 10 year old cannot learn guitar, piano, chess, etc. just because they are small. To make coding an intellectual avenue for the olds is just a statement to satisfy the ego of these mediocre minds. Don't children learn language, or music? What makes you think they cannot learn coding. Coding is not about competing in Codechef(as most of these people do to get jobs), it's pattern matching and problem solving which is an integral part of growing up and intellectual development. I find the whole argument against the idea of kids doing coding so abhorrent. Having said that, I don't agree with Whitehat's promotional tactics. But hey, can you really blame them when a majority of India's population is motivated by financial prospects? I can count a great chunk of people who started doing coding just to get high-paying job.
好吧，这种拖放被称为“抓取”，是在麻省理工学院创建并用来教授编程的。那些反对教孩子们学习编程，说一个10岁的孩子不能这么做的“平庸”之人，并不能理解，事实编程什么都不是，重点是学会解决问题的方法。这就好比说一个10岁的孩子不能学习吉他、钢琴、国际象棋等，因为他们很小。
让编码成为年龄较大的人的智力游戏，只是为了满足这些平庸头脑自我的一种说法。孩子们不学习语言或音乐吗？是什么让你认为他们无法学习编码。学习编码不是要让他们像大多数人一样去Codechef（程序员刷题网站）上去竞争，而是学会模式匹配和问题解决，这是成长和智力发展不可或缺的一部分。
我觉得反对孩子们做编码的整个论点是如此令人憎恶。话虽如此，我不同意Whitehat的促销策略。但嘿，当印度大多数人口都被金融前景所驱动时，你真的能责怪他们吗？我可以统计出很多人开始做代码只是为了得到一份高薪工作。
Kanthaswamy Balasubramaniam
Teaching code to kids free- Fun. No.issues
Claiming to teach kids coding by paying 1 lakh to develop apps worth billions or to go to silicon valley to meet google or facebook - CON. CON.CON.
If kids wanna learn - Sure
Forcing a kid to.learn programming - Disaster
If a 10 yr old is learning the guitar - Fun
Pressurizing a 10 yo to join nirvana or van halen - Disaster
Thats all i say.
The kind of programming needed to create apps that people pay money for - No kid except those with iqs of 170+ can.create.
免费教孩子们学习代码——娱乐活动。没有争议。
声称通过支付10万美元，就能让你的孩子学会开发价值十亿美元的应用程序，或者去硅谷与谷歌或facebook面试——反对、反对、反对。
如果孩子们想学习——可以
强迫孩子学习编程——灾难
如果一个10岁的孩子在学吉他——娱乐活动
给一个10岁的孩子施加压力，让他们加入nirvana乐队或者van halen乐队——灾难
我就是这么看的。
写一个能让人花钱购买的应用程序，要达到这个能力——除了智商超过170的孩子，别的孩子都做不到。
Teaching code to kids free- Fun. No.issues
Claiming to teach kids coding by paying 1 lakh to develop apps worth billions or to go to silicon valley to meet google or facebook - CON. CON.CON.
If kids wanna learn - Sure
Forcing a kid to.learn programming - Disaster
If a 10 yr old is learning the guitar - Fun
Pressurizing a 10 yo to join nirvana or van halen - Disaster
Thats all i say.
The kind of programming needed to create apps that people pay money for - No kid except those with iqs of 170+ can.create.
免费教孩子们学习代码——娱乐活动。没有争议。
声称通过支付10万美元，就能让你的孩子学会开发价值十亿美元的应用程序，或者去硅谷与谷歌或facebook面试——反对、反对、反对。
如果孩子们想学习——可以
强迫孩子学习编程——灾难
如果一个10岁的孩子在学吉他——娱乐活动
给一个10岁的孩子施加压力，让他们加入nirvana乐队或者van halen乐队——灾难
我就是这么看的。
写一个能让人花钱购买的应用程序，要达到这个能力——除了智商超过170的孩子，别的孩子都做不到。
Akash Manoj
sir he is just some white hat junior’s social media advocate and if we write anything wrong against them they will take us down by mass reporting and some logical comments which is not applicable to white hat jr (not even 1%) of it and i think you forgot to add “we will learn python in java” told by a white hat teacher which was subject to mass trolling
先生，他只是Whitehat的社交媒体倡导者，如果我们对他们写了什么错误的话，他们会通过大量报道和一些不适用于Whitehat（甚至不到1%）的逻辑评论来打倒我们，我想你忘了加上一位Whitehat老师告诉我们的话：“我们将学习java中的python”，这个老师受到了大规模的攻击。
sir he is just some white hat junior’s social media advocate and if we write anything wrong against them they will take us down by mass reporting and some logical comments which is not applicable to white hat jr (not even 1%) of it and i think you forgot to add “we will learn python in java” told by a white hat teacher which was subject to mass trolling
先生，他只是Whitehat的社交媒体倡导者，如果我们对他们写了什么错误的话，他们会通过大量报道和一些不适用于Whitehat（甚至不到1%）的逻辑评论来打倒我们，我想你忘了加上一位Whitehat老师告诉我们的话：“我们将学习java中的python”，这个老师受到了大规模的攻击。
Ganesh Kendre
How do you know if kids are being forced into ? Kids if it’s too much for them will just throw up and this is online so there isn’t much forcing involved . Now I just feel it’s not constructive criticism most people in comment section are just just pouring insecurities. Your kids were 150 IQ you got lucky not all are that lucky so they do their best by spending money on frivolous things like white hat jr and international schools .
你怎么知道孩子们是否被强迫？如果孩子们受不了，他们会愤怒，这是在线的，所以没有太多的强迫。现在我只是觉得这不是建设性的批评，评论区的大多数人只是在倾诉不安全感。你的孩子智商是150，你很幸运，并不是所有的孩子都那么幸运，所以他们会把钱花在一些别的东西上，比如whitehat和国际学校。
How do you know if kids are being forced into ? Kids if it’s too much for them will just throw up and this is online so there isn’t much forcing involved . Now I just feel it’s not constructive criticism most people in comment section are just just pouring insecurities. Your kids were 150 IQ you got lucky not all are that lucky so they do their best by spending money on frivolous things like white hat jr and international schools .
你怎么知道孩子们是否被强迫？如果孩子们受不了，他们会愤怒，这是在线的，所以没有太多的强迫。现在我只是觉得这不是建设性的批评，评论区的大多数人只是在倾诉不安全感。你的孩子智商是150，你很幸运，并不是所有的孩子都那么幸运，所以他们会把钱花在一些别的东西上，比如whitehat和国际学校。
Kavin S
Seriously? You don't think Indian parents are not or can't force anything on their child? Even higher education of most of the students are chosen based on the pressure of parents.
认真的吗？你认为印度父母没有或者不会强迫他们的孩子吗？甚至大多数学生的高等教育都是基于父母的压力而选择的。
Seriously? You don't think Indian parents are not or can't force anything on their child? Even higher education of most of the students are chosen based on the pressure of parents.
认真的吗？你认为印度父母没有或者不会强迫他们的孩子吗？甚至大多数学生的高等教育都是基于父母的压力而选择的。
Ganesh Kendre
Yes parents do force that’s true of you . I am saying specifically about white hat jr case . Given the age nature of the content (Online ) Not much can be forced plus it’s the upper middle class or above strata that mostly takes white hat jr. They do have some sense instill.
是的，父母确实会强迫你这样做。我在这里特别指出了whitehat的课程是线上的，考虑到年龄性质，没有多少可以强迫的，加上大部分接受whitehat教育的都是中上层或以上阶层。他们更多的只是理智的逐步灌输。
Yes parents do force that’s true of you . I am saying specifically about white hat jr case . Given the age nature of the content (Online ) Not much can be forced plus it’s the upper middle class or above strata that mostly takes white hat jr. They do have some sense instill.
是的，父母确实会强迫你这样做。我在这里特别指出了whitehat的课程是线上的，考虑到年龄性质，没有多少可以强迫的，加上大部分接受whitehat教育的都是中上层或以上阶层。他们更多的只是理智的逐步灌输。
Kavin S
Middle and lower middle class are more vulnerable to such produts. They are desperate to provide a better life than theirs for their kids which is used by these companies. These companies push easy emi schemes which will make sure that even lower middle class can afford it.
Its not a question about price. If the kids gets 1 on 1 classes with good programmers then that price is very much justified. The only issue is quality of teachers.
中产阶级和中下阶层更容易受到此类产品的影响。他们不顾一切地为孩子们提供比他们更好的生活，而这些公司正利用这一点。这些公司推行简单的等额每月分期付款计划，这将确保即使是低收入的中产阶级也能负担得起。
这不是价格问题。如果孩子们得到了优秀程序员的1对1课程，那么这个价格是非常合理的。唯一的问题是教师的质量。
Middle and lower middle class are more vulnerable to such produts. They are desperate to provide a better life than theirs for their kids which is used by these companies. These companies push easy emi schemes which will make sure that even lower middle class can afford it.
Its not a question about price. If the kids gets 1 on 1 classes with good programmers then that price is very much justified. The only issue is quality of teachers.
中产阶级和中下阶层更容易受到此类产品的影响。他们不顾一切地为孩子们提供比他们更好的生活，而这些公司正利用这一点。这些公司推行简单的等额每月分期付款计划，这将确保即使是低收入的中产阶级也能负担得起。
这不是价格问题。如果孩子们得到了优秀程序员的1对1课程，那么这个价格是非常合理的。唯一的问题是教师的质量。
Ganesh Kendre
Agree to all points of yours. Only thing is there’s little difference in white hat jr and other products. It’s that right now white hat jr I feel is catering to upper middle class and Lower like Byjus does
同意你的所有观点。唯一的一点是，whitehat和其他产品还是有区别的。现在whitehat像Byjus一样在迎合中上层和下层。
Agree to all points of yours. Only thing is there’s little difference in white hat jr and other products. It’s that right now white hat jr I feel is catering to upper middle class and Lower like Byjus does
同意你的所有观点。唯一的一点是，whitehat和其他产品还是有区别的。现在whitehat像Byjus一样在迎合中上层和下层。
Kavin S
Maybe you're right. But even if someone who buy a product can easily afford it that doesn't mean selling a bad product is ok. Even if we pay 10 rupees for something we should get a product worth that price. And right now I don't think parents who buy WHJ products get anything remotely worthy of that price tag.
也许你是对的。但是，即使购买产品的人很容易负担得起，这并不意味着销售一个糟糕的产品是可以的。我们花10卢比购买一个产品，我们也应该得到一个值这个价格的产品。现在，我不认为购买whitehat产品的父母会得到任何与这个价格标签相称的东西。
Maybe you're right. But even if someone who buy a product can easily afford it that doesn't mean selling a bad product is ok. Even if we pay 10 rupees for something we should get a product worth that price. And right now I don't think parents who buy WHJ products get anything remotely worthy of that price tag.
也许你是对的。但是，即使购买产品的人很容易负担得起，这并不意味着销售一个糟糕的产品是可以的。我们花10卢比购买一个产品，我们也应该得到一个值这个价格的产品。现在，我不认为购买whitehat产品的父母会得到任何与这个价格标签相称的东西。
Aditya Vardhan Gundla
Sir, all robots need not be humanoid. Different purpose need different types of robots. A humanoid robot that can walk, jump and balance properly will be much costlier than a robot on wheels. A restaurant wanting to employ robot servers will find it better to buy the latter ones as they serve their purpose at lower costs.
先生，并非所有的机器人都需要人形。不同的目的需要不同类型的机器人。一个能够正确行走、跳跃和平衡的人形机器人将比一个带轮子的机器人昂贵得多。想要使用机器人服务的餐厅会发现最好购买后者，因为后者以较低的成本实现其目的。
Sir, all robots need not be humanoid. Different purpose need different types of robots. A humanoid robot that can walk, jump and balance properly will be much costlier than a robot on wheels. A restaurant wanting to employ robot servers will find it better to buy the latter ones as they serve their purpose at lower costs.
先生，并非所有的机器人都需要人形。不同的目的需要不同类型的机器人。一个能够正确行走、跳跃和平衡的人形机器人将比一个带轮子的机器人昂贵得多。想要使用机器人服务的餐厅会发现最好购买后者，因为后者以较低的成本实现其目的。
Kopparthi Bharadwaj
This hyping is not just native to India and you are naive if you think it happens only in India. The issue is with startup culture all across the globe. People start a mediocre product and start procuring funds from venture capitalists. Those that get on the wagon early hype the product to every one in their circle to increase valuation in the next rounds. After few rounds the initial investors exit with safe profits. So, in order to make money in startup world you don't have to bet on great companies, you can bet on mediocre companies too along as you can hype it and exit when the right time comes.
这种炒作不仅仅是印度会有，如果你认为它只发生在印度，那你就太天真了。问题在于全球各地的创业文化。人们开始一个平庸的产品，并开始从风险资本家那里获取资金。那些早早上车的人向他们圈子里的每一个人宣传产品，以提高下一轮的估值。几轮之后，最初的投资者以安全的利润退出。所以，为了在创业世界中赚钱，你不必押注于伟大的公司，你也可以押注平庸的公司，因为你可以炒作它，并在合适的时候退出。
This hyping is not just native to India and you are naive if you think it happens only in India. The issue is with startup culture all across the globe. People start a mediocre product and start procuring funds from venture capitalists. Those that get on the wagon early hype the product to every one in their circle to increase valuation in the next rounds. After few rounds the initial investors exit with safe profits. So, in order to make money in startup world you don't have to bet on great companies, you can bet on mediocre companies too along as you can hype it and exit when the right time comes.
这种炒作不仅仅是印度会有，如果你认为它只发生在印度，那你就太天真了。问题在于全球各地的创业文化。人们开始一个平庸的产品，并开始从风险资本家那里获取资金。那些早早上车的人向他们圈子里的每一个人宣传产品，以提高下一轮的估值。几轮之后，最初的投资者以安全的利润退出。所以，为了在创业世界中赚钱，你不必押注于伟大的公司，你也可以押注平庸的公司，因为你可以炒作它，并在合适的时候退出。
Nikhil Patil
Whitehat JR is pure scam. Had it been a legit app, it would not face such a criticism. But Whitehat and Byju both don't teach kids ANYTHING AT ALL. They just scam parents of money and that's all. It's the biggest scam in Indian History.
Whitehat 纯属骗局。如果它是一个规规矩矩的应用程序，它就不会面临这样的批评。Whitehat 和Byju 都根本教不了孩子什么，他们只是骗取父母的钱，仅此而已。这是印度历史上最大的骗局。
Whitehat JR is pure scam. Had it been a legit app, it would not face such a criticism. But Whitehat and Byju both don't teach kids ANYTHING AT ALL. They just scam parents of money and that's all. It's the biggest scam in Indian History.
Whitehat 纯属骗局。如果它是一个规规矩矩的应用程序，它就不会面临这样的批评。Whitehat 和Byju 都根本教不了孩子什么，他们只是骗取父母的钱，仅此而已。这是印度历史上最大的骗局。
Manish Gupta
The mentality never change. I moved to Finland couple of years ago because I read they have best education system in the world. Their education is very different - current, practical and lot of freedom. They are not really teaching anything.. but what they are doing is getting the best potential out of everyone. However, most of the Indians I met here have same complaint - they want Finland eduction system to be like India. They feel like their kids are lacking behind their relatives in India because they are cramming too many things in indian schools. My answer to them is - if you want Indian education system, go to India. If you come to Finland for finnish education system, then have trust in their system.
心态永远不会改变。几年前我搬到了芬兰，因为我读到他们有世界上最好的教育系统。他们的教育是非常不同的——当前的、实用的和自由的。他们并没有真正教什么……但他们所做的是从每个人身上挖掘出最好的潜力。然而，我在这里遇到的大多数印度人都有同样的抱怨——他们希望芬兰的教育制度像印度一样。他们觉得自己的孩子学得太少了，因为他们在印度的亲戚的孩子在印度学校里被填满了太多的东西。我对他们的回答是——如果你想要印度的教育体系，那就去印度。如果你来芬兰是为了芬兰的教育系统，那么就要信任他们的系统。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
The mentality never change. I moved to Finland couple of years ago because I read they have best education system in the world. Their education is very different - current, practical and lot of freedom. They are not really teaching anything.. but what they are doing is getting the best potential out of everyone. However, most of the Indians I met here have same complaint - they want Finland eduction system to be like India. They feel like their kids are lacking behind their relatives in India because they are cramming too many things in indian schools. My answer to them is - if you want Indian education system, go to India. If you come to Finland for finnish education system, then have trust in their system.
心态永远不会改变。几年前我搬到了芬兰，因为我读到他们有世界上最好的教育系统。他们的教育是非常不同的——当前的、实用的和自由的。他们并没有真正教什么……但他们所做的是从每个人身上挖掘出最好的潜力。然而，我在这里遇到的大多数印度人都有同样的抱怨——他们希望芬兰的教育制度像印度一样。他们觉得自己的孩子学得太少了，因为他们在印度的亲戚的孩子在印度学校里被填满了太多的东西。我对他们的回答是——如果你想要印度的教育体系，那就去印度。如果你来芬兰是为了芬兰的教育系统，那么就要信任他们的系统。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Rohan Shenoy
Some entrepreneurs are injecting cognitive biases such as ‘coding is an essential skills’, ‘knowing coding means being progressive’, ‘child will be a failure without knowing coding’ to sell their products and make money. In the process of injecting cognitive biases, they intentionally conceal facts, make false claims, exaggerate the truth, and are eventually grilled by authentic real-worlders.
“Don't they want India to make progress and help kids learn in the process?” Do you want Indian kids to live under a false perception of being progressive where in the fact is that programming taught is sub-standard? Is gratification kids and their gullible parents is all that you want? If you train them around low-standards, these ‘progressive kids’ will grow up to become adolescents and adults who are unable to cope up with the real struggle and end up visiting psychiatrists for depression and anxiety.
The entrepreneur should choose one:
Either he should be focussed on selling instant gratification to naive kids and their gullible parents.
Or he should train for real-world competition.
Using the pretense of ‘training for real-world competition’ where in fact all that is happening is selling of substandard product/service to naive kids and their gullible parents is worse than being a failed entrepreneur. Its blatant cheating or act of 420! Let the entrepreneur choose between ‘a failed entrepreneur’ vs ‘cheater + failed entrepreneur’.
一些企业家正在注入认知偏见，如：“编码是一项基本技能”、“知道编码意味着进步”、“不知道编码的孩子会失败”，以销售他们的产品并赚钱。在注入认知偏见的过程中，他们故意隐瞒事实，做出虚假声明，夸大真相，最终受到真实世界的质疑。
“难道他们不希望印度取得进步，并在这个过程中帮助孩子们学习吗？”
你想让印度孩子生活在一种虚假的进步观念下吗？事实上，在这种观念下，所教的编程是不合格的？满足孩子和他们轻信的父母是你想要的吗？如果你围绕低标准训练他们，这些“进步的孩子”将成长为青少年和成年人，他们无法应对真正的竞争，最终会因抑郁和焦虑而去看精神科医生。
企业家应该选择一个：
1、要么他应该专注于向天真的孩子和他们容易上当的父母推销即时满足感。
2、或者他应该为现实世界的比赛而进行培训。
用“为真实世界的竞争而培训”的幌子，事实上所发生的一切都是向天真的孩子和他们容易上当的父母销售不合格的产品/服务，这比成为一个失败的企业家更糟糕。这是赤裸裸的作弊或420行为！让创业者在“失败的创业者”和“骗子+失败的创业家”之间做出选择。
Some entrepreneurs are injecting cognitive biases such as ‘coding is an essential skills’, ‘knowing coding means being progressive’, ‘child will be a failure without knowing coding’ to sell their products and make money. In the process of injecting cognitive biases, they intentionally conceal facts, make false claims, exaggerate the truth, and are eventually grilled by authentic real-worlders.
“Don't they want India to make progress and help kids learn in the process?” Do you want Indian kids to live under a false perception of being progressive where in the fact is that programming taught is sub-standard? Is gratification kids and their gullible parents is all that you want? If you train them around low-standards, these ‘progressive kids’ will grow up to become adolescents and adults who are unable to cope up with the real struggle and end up visiting psychiatrists for depression and anxiety.
The entrepreneur should choose one:
Either he should be focussed on selling instant gratification to naive kids and their gullible parents.
Or he should train for real-world competition.
Using the pretense of ‘training for real-world competition’ where in fact all that is happening is selling of substandard product/service to naive kids and their gullible parents is worse than being a failed entrepreneur. Its blatant cheating or act of 420! Let the entrepreneur choose between ‘a failed entrepreneur’ vs ‘cheater + failed entrepreneur’.
一些企业家正在注入认知偏见，如：“编码是一项基本技能”、“知道编码意味着进步”、“不知道编码的孩子会失败”，以销售他们的产品并赚钱。在注入认知偏见的过程中，他们故意隐瞒事实，做出虚假声明，夸大真相，最终受到真实世界的质疑。
“难道他们不希望印度取得进步，并在这个过程中帮助孩子们学习吗？”
你想让印度孩子生活在一种虚假的进步观念下吗？事实上，在这种观念下，所教的编程是不合格的？满足孩子和他们轻信的父母是你想要的吗？如果你围绕低标准训练他们，这些“进步的孩子”将成长为青少年和成年人，他们无法应对真正的竞争，最终会因抑郁和焦虑而去看精神科医生。
企业家应该选择一个：
1、要么他应该专注于向天真的孩子和他们容易上当的父母推销即时满足感。
2、或者他应该为现实世界的比赛而进行培训。
用“为真实世界的竞争而培训”的幌子，事实上所发生的一切都是向天真的孩子和他们容易上当的父母销售不合格的产品/服务，这比成为一个失败的企业家更糟糕。这是赤裸裸的作弊或420行为！让创业者在“失败的创业者”和“骗子+失败的创业家”之间做出选择。
Pankaj Kumar Ukey
Before answering this question, let me present the information about me. I am not a programmer. I belong to the hardcore engineering sector: oil and Gas. I learned C programming during the first year of college. So the answer would be based on my short stint with programming:
To create a program one needs to understand the algorithm which is based on logic. Program is just a language which can be learned but to create something extraordinary out of it, the algorithm is the base of it. To learn an algorithm, one needs to work on his logic and aptitude skill. For some people, these skills come naturally and for others, they acquire it by hard work.
In both of the cases, skills require time to build up. A child can learn the format of the programming language but that would be a waste unless and until his logical and analytical skills were developed.
I don't know what do they teach in Whitehat but it doesn't make sense to let a child learn the programming language at the time when he is supposed to invest in developing his creative brain.
If they are teaching the “Copy-paste programming” then it is equivalent to the classroom in state Hindi medium school where they let the child mug up everything written in English and claim that they have taught English to the students.
在回答这个问题之前，让我先介绍一下关于我的信息。我不是程序员。我属于核心工程部门：石油和天然气。我在大学第一年学习了C语言。因此，答案将基于我短暂的编程经历：
要创建程序，需要理解基于逻辑的算法。程序只是一种可以学习的语言，但要从中创造非凡的东西，算法是它的基础。要学习算法，一个人需要有逻辑和分析技能。对于一些人来说，这些技能是自然而然的，而对于其他人来说，他们是通过努力学习获得的。
在这两种情况下，技能都需要时间来积累。一个孩子可以学习编程语言的格式，但这将是一种浪费，这东西要等到他的逻辑和分析技能得到发展的时候才有用。
我不知道Whitehat在教什么，但在孩子们还没有开发创造性大脑的时候，让他学习编程语言是没有意义的。
如果他们教的是“复制粘贴编程”，那么这就相当于州立印地语中学的教室，在那里他们让孩子背所有用英语写的东西，并声称他们已经教过学生英语了。
Before answering this question, let me present the information about me. I am not a programmer. I belong to the hardcore engineering sector: oil and Gas. I learned C programming during the first year of college. So the answer would be based on my short stint with programming:
To create a program one needs to understand the algorithm which is based on logic. Program is just a language which can be learned but to create something extraordinary out of it, the algorithm is the base of it. To learn an algorithm, one needs to work on his logic and aptitude skill. For some people, these skills come naturally and for others, they acquire it by hard work.
In both of the cases, skills require time to build up. A child can learn the format of the programming language but that would be a waste unless and until his logical and analytical skills were developed.
I don't know what do they teach in Whitehat but it doesn't make sense to let a child learn the programming language at the time when he is supposed to invest in developing his creative brain.
If they are teaching the “Copy-paste programming” then it is equivalent to the classroom in state Hindi medium school where they let the child mug up everything written in English and claim that they have taught English to the students.
在回答这个问题之前，让我先介绍一下关于我的信息。我不是程序员。我属于核心工程部门：石油和天然气。我在大学第一年学习了C语言。因此，答案将基于我短暂的编程经历：
要创建程序，需要理解基于逻辑的算法。程序只是一种可以学习的语言，但要从中创造非凡的东西，算法是它的基础。要学习算法，一个人需要有逻辑和分析技能。对于一些人来说，这些技能是自然而然的，而对于其他人来说，他们是通过努力学习获得的。
在这两种情况下，技能都需要时间来积累。一个孩子可以学习编程语言的格式，但这将是一种浪费，这东西要等到他的逻辑和分析技能得到发展的时候才有用。
我不知道Whitehat在教什么，但在孩子们还没有开发创造性大脑的时候，让他学习编程语言是没有意义的。
如果他们教的是“复制粘贴编程”，那么这就相当于州立印地语中学的教室，在那里他们让孩子背所有用英语写的东西，并声称他们已经教过学生英语了。
很赞 1
收藏