莫迪欲推出数字卢比，印度网友热烈讨论利弊
正文翻译
许多人对我上一篇关于数字卢比会导致绝对极权主义国家的文章不以为然。因此，我在此作出反驳。
1 数字卢比将只存在于虚拟世界。它没有实体形式。
2 你不能以实体纸币的形式从银行提取它。
3 你可以使用它的唯一方法是通过使用UPI等在线系统进行虚拟消费。
4 因此政府知道你把每一笔钱使用在了什么地方。
5 你不能在不让任何人知道你花钱的地方的情况下取出那笔钱并私下花掉。
6 政府想对你的消费习惯进行纳米级管理。
现在，最糟糕的情况出现了
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Modi govt is bringing Digital Rupee ‘e₹’ and here's why it is dangerous and a death-knell on our freedom to chose where to spend our own money.
莫迪政府正在推出数字卢比“₹”，这就是为什么它是危险的，也是我们选择把钱花在哪里的自由的丧钟。
莫迪政府正在推出数字卢比“₹”，这就是为什么它是危险的，也是我们选择把钱花在哪里的自由的丧钟。
许多人对我上一篇关于数字卢比会导致绝对极权主义国家的文章不以为然。因此，我在此作出反驳。
1 数字卢比将只存在于虚拟世界。它没有实体形式。
2 你不能以实体纸币的形式从银行提取它。
3 你可以使用它的唯一方法是通过使用UPI等在线系统进行虚拟消费。
4 因此政府知道你把每一笔钱使用在了什么地方。
5 你不能在不让任何人知道你花钱的地方的情况下取出那笔钱并私下花掉。
6 政府想对你的消费习惯进行纳米级管理。
现在，最糟糕的情况出现了
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
评论翻译
Government wants to nano-manage your spending habits.
NOW COMES THE WORST SCENARIOS
Specific purpose digital rupee: Since everything is digital, govt now lixs money to specific purpose. This is already happening. Govt is planning to give urea subsidies to farmers as digital rupees which can only be used for urea purchases.
Imagine your employer giving you your salary with purpose-lixed digital rupee. Let’s say you earn 25000 digital rupees but it is purpose lixed. Say 5000 for groceries, 2000 for fuel, 12000 for rent, 2000 for leisure. Then you can’t spend more than 2000 for leisure activity even though you have money in your account.
Modi is not going to stay here forever. All it takes is a crooked government to control 100% of your money and keep track of every paisa you ever own.
This is what the Klaus Schwab - Soros mafia wants in the world. This is the final step of The Great Reset. All governments are together on this one. China is just ahead of the game and has already implemented it to some degree.
Say no to Digital Rupee e₹
EDIT: For those simping for the govt and lapping up everything they introduce —
Go search for Purpose lixed Digital Currency and how it works. This is not Modi’s brainchild. The whole Digital Currency nonsense is developed by the Klaus Schwab - Soros global financial mafia sitting in the World Economic Forum.
Go read about what’s happening in China with Digital Yuan instead of simping for the govt. Some time in the future there will be Congress government. Just imagine what they will do with digital rupee.
1 特定用途的数字卢比：由于所有东西都是数字化的，政府现在将钱与特定用途联系起来。这已经在发生了。政府正计划将尿素补贴以数字卢比的形式发放给农民，这些钱只能用于购买尿素。
2 想象一下，你的雇主用与目的挂钩的数字卢比给你发工资。假设你赚了25000数字卢比，但它是与目的挂钩的。比如说5000只能用于购买杂货，2000只能用于购买燃料，12000只能用于支付房租，2000只能用于休闲。那么，即使你的账户里有钱，你也不能花超过2000的钱进行休闲活动。
莫迪不会永远止步于此。他想要的是一个狡猾的能100%控制你的钱，并跟踪你拥有的每一分钱的政府。
这就是克劳斯-施瓦布-索罗斯的黑手党在这个世界上想要的东西。这是大重置的最后一步。所有政府在这一点上都是一致的。中国只是走在了游戏的前面，并且已经在某种程度上实施了它。
对数字卢比说不。
NOW COMES THE WORST SCENARIOS
Specific purpose digital rupee: Since everything is digital, govt now lixs money to specific purpose. This is already happening. Govt is planning to give urea subsidies to farmers as digital rupees which can only be used for urea purchases.
Imagine your employer giving you your salary with purpose-lixed digital rupee. Let’s say you earn 25000 digital rupees but it is purpose lixed. Say 5000 for groceries, 2000 for fuel, 12000 for rent, 2000 for leisure. Then you can’t spend more than 2000 for leisure activity even though you have money in your account.
Modi is not going to stay here forever. All it takes is a crooked government to control 100% of your money and keep track of every paisa you ever own.
This is what the Klaus Schwab - Soros mafia wants in the world. This is the final step of The Great Reset. All governments are together on this one. China is just ahead of the game and has already implemented it to some degree.
Say no to Digital Rupee e₹
EDIT: For those simping for the govt and lapping up everything they introduce —
Go search for Purpose lixed Digital Currency and how it works. This is not Modi’s brainchild. The whole Digital Currency nonsense is developed by the Klaus Schwab - Soros global financial mafia sitting in the World Economic Forum.
Go read about what’s happening in China with Digital Yuan instead of simping for the govt. Some time in the future there will be Congress government. Just imagine what they will do with digital rupee.
1 特定用途的数字卢比：由于所有东西都是数字化的，政府现在将钱与特定用途联系起来。这已经在发生了。政府正计划将尿素补贴以数字卢比的形式发放给农民，这些钱只能用于购买尿素。
2 想象一下，你的雇主用与目的挂钩的数字卢比给你发工资。假设你赚了25000数字卢比，但它是与目的挂钩的。比如说5000只能用于购买杂货，2000只能用于购买燃料，12000只能用于支付房租，2000只能用于休闲。那么，即使你的账户里有钱，你也不能花超过2000的钱进行休闲活动。
莫迪不会永远止步于此。他想要的是一个狡猾的能100%控制你的钱，并跟踪你拥有的每一分钱的政府。
这就是克劳斯-施瓦布-索罗斯的黑手党在这个世界上想要的东西。这是大重置的最后一步。所有政府在这一点上都是一致的。中国只是走在了游戏的前面，并且已经在某种程度上实施了它。
对数字卢比说不。
woke_ka_choda
To me this sounds good. I dont have to carry my stupid wallet. And BTW the government still knows your every move. Everything is digital. Your post seems like a shopkeeper or a small business favouring post.
Because they are the ones who do business in raw cash. The reason behind is they don't have to pay taxes. They are also the ones who evade taxes just like large businesses owners.
And BTW the employer purpose lixed digital rupee thing you said, the government can still do it WITHOUT digital rupee. You don't get your salary in CASH.
对我来说，这听起来不错。我再也不需要带着我那愚蠢的钱包了。而且，政府本来就知道你的一举一动。一切都是数字化的。你的帖子似乎是一个店主或小企业者会赞成的帖子。
因为他们是那些用原始现金做生意的人。背后的原因是他们不需要交税。他们也是那些像大企业主一样逃税的人。
还有，你说的雇主发薪与数字卢比挂钩的事情，政府仍然可以在没有数字卢比的情况下这么做。你本来就不会以现金形式获得你的工资。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
To me this sounds good. I dont have to carry my stupid wallet. And BTW the government still knows your every move. Everything is digital. Your post seems like a shopkeeper or a small business favouring post.
Because they are the ones who do business in raw cash. The reason behind is they don't have to pay taxes. They are also the ones who evade taxes just like large businesses owners.
And BTW the employer purpose lixed digital rupee thing you said, the government can still do it WITHOUT digital rupee. You don't get your salary in CASH.
对我来说，这听起来不错。我再也不需要带着我那愚蠢的钱包了。而且，政府本来就知道你的一举一动。一切都是数字化的。你的帖子似乎是一个店主或小企业者会赞成的帖子。
因为他们是那些用原始现金做生意的人。背后的原因是他们不需要交税。他们也是那些像大企业主一样逃税的人。
还有，你说的雇主发薪与数字卢比挂钩的事情，政府仍然可以在没有数字卢比的情况下这么做。你本来就不会以现金形式获得你的工资。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Advanced-Attempt4293
The no 2 scenario is impossible or it will take many many years. The digital rupees will help in caching the tax evaders. There are many people in my area, who earn more than 10 million rupees per year and still pay 0 tax.
他说的第2种情况是不可能的，或者需要很多很多年。数字卢比将有助于追踪逃税者。在我所在的地区，有很多人每年收入超过1000万卢比，但仍然不交税。
The no 2 scenario is impossible or it will take many many years. The digital rupees will help in caching the tax evaders. There are many people in my area, who earn more than 10 million rupees per year and still pay 0 tax.
他说的第2种情况是不可能的，或者需要很多很多年。数字卢比将有助于追踪逃税者。在我所在的地区，有很多人每年收入超过1000万卢比，但仍然不交税。
exorcis
OP
It won’t take many years. China has already implemented it. Once everything is digital, it just takes a flick of a switch to change things.
这并不需要很多年。中国已经实施了它。一旦一切都是数字化的，它只需按一下开关就可以改变事情。
OP
It won’t take many years. China has already implemented it. Once everything is digital, it just takes a flick of a switch to change things.
这并不需要很多年。中国已经实施了它。一旦一切都是数字化的，它只需按一下开关就可以改变事情。
IAmAPaInInYourasS
China and India are not the same
中国跟印度不一样
China and India are not the same
中国跟印度不一样
NOTHINGHARMLESS
Not same but India is following china's footsteps since Modi came in power
虽然不一样，但自莫迪上台以来，印度一直在追随中国的脚步
Not same but India is following china's footsteps since Modi came in power
虽然不一样，但自莫迪上台以来，印度一直在追随中国的脚步
yeceti
You people will never understand why it is bad to give extra powers to the government unless one day you get arrested on ‘sedition’ charges for sending 10 Rs. to a friend who is a member of an opposition party/religion/faction whatever.
你们这些人永远不会明白为什么给政府额外的权力是不好的，除非有一天你因为给一个反对党/宗教/派别成员的朋友寄了10卢比而被以"煽动"的罪名逮捕。
You people will never understand why it is bad to give extra powers to the government unless one day you get arrested on ‘sedition’ charges for sending 10 Rs. to a friend who is a member of an opposition party/religion/faction whatever.
你们这些人永远不会明白为什么给政府额外的权力是不好的，除非有一天你因为给一个反对党/宗教/派别成员的朋友寄了10卢比而被以"煽动"的罪名逮捕。
woke_ka_choda
Can't the government still do it ?
你觉得现在没办法这么干吗？
Can't the government still do it ?
你觉得现在没办法这么干吗？
yeceti
But it’s very different with a CBDC like Digital Rupee.
Now, only the from and to accounts can be tracked and the story ends there. With Digital Rupee, every rupee can be tracked right from the time it originates in RBI servers till today, where all it has been and what is the chain of transfers.
但是有了像数字卢比这样的CBDC（中央数字货币）就很不一样了。
现在只能跟踪发件人和收件人帐户，故事到此结束。而有了数字卢比，每一个卢比都可以被追踪到，从它在 RBI 服务器中产生的那一刻起，它都去了哪里，转移的链条是什么。
But it’s very different with a CBDC like Digital Rupee.
Now, only the from and to accounts can be tracked and the story ends there. With Digital Rupee, every rupee can be tracked right from the time it originates in RBI servers till today, where all it has been and what is the chain of transfers.
但是有了像数字卢比这样的CBDC（中央数字货币）就很不一样了。
现在只能跟踪发件人和收件人帐户，故事到此结束。而有了数字卢比，每一个卢比都可以被追踪到，从它在 RBI 服务器中产生的那一刻起，它都去了哪里，转移的链条是什么。
brozoned367
Take of your tinfoil hat bro
少发点阴谋论兄弟
Take of your tinfoil hat bro
少发点阴谋论兄弟
Physical-Program-180
Completely agree. I wouldn't mind if the govt knows where i am spending my money if it's able to curb corruption and tax evasion.
“对我来说，这听起来不错。”
完全同意。如果政府能够遏制腐败和逃税，我不会介意政府知道我的钱花在哪里。
Completely agree. I wouldn't mind if the govt knows where i am spending my money if it's able to curb corruption and tax evasion.
“对我来说，这听起来不错。”
完全同意。如果政府能够遏制腐败和逃税，我不会介意政府知道我的钱花在哪里。
Ok-Importance-8613
curb corruption and tax evasion
curb corruption and tax evasion only for middle-class. Do you really think rich corrupts will not be able to get away?
“遏制腐败和逃税”
遏制腐败和偷税漏税只针对中产阶级。你真的认为那些真正富有的腐败者会没办法逃脱吗？
curb corruption and tax evasion
curb corruption and tax evasion only for middle-class. Do you really think rich corrupts will not be able to get away?
“遏制腐败和逃税”
遏制腐败和偷税漏税只针对中产阶级。你真的认为那些真正富有的腐败者会没办法逃脱吗？
cerebrite
Do people really think rich corrupts are godly or unreachable? Such small changes eventually and surely tighten the leash around corruption, unless people have already given up on it and just can't accept any changes and efforts toward making that possible.
人们真的认为有钱的腐败分子是神一般的存在，或者是高不可攀的吗？像这样的小变化最终肯定会收紧对腐败的束缚，除非大家都以这样的借口（对真正的有钱人没什么用blabla）摆烂，不接受任何变化和努力，反而会使他们口中的情况成为可能。
Do people really think rich corrupts are godly or unreachable? Such small changes eventually and surely tighten the leash around corruption, unless people have already given up on it and just can't accept any changes and efforts toward making that possible.
人们真的认为有钱的腐败分子是神一般的存在，或者是高不可攀的吗？像这样的小变化最终肯定会收紧对腐败的束缚，除非大家都以这样的借口（对真正的有钱人没什么用blabla）摆烂，不接受任何变化和努力，反而会使他们口中的情况成为可能。
Gigachandriya
I mean just look at the USA.....
咱就是说，只要看看美国.....
I mean just look at the USA.....
咱就是说，只要看看美国.....
devilsarmpit666
You say as if any government has ever done anything to curb corruption and tax evasion. They want people like you and me to pay more tax so that they can steal more from it. If doing this means there will be complete transparency and everyone will pay their fair share of taxes, then it would be good but let's be honest that is never going to happen. Corruption is one thing that is universal in Indian politics, which goes beyond party lines.
你说得好像哪一届政府曾为遏制腐败和逃税做过什么似的。他们希望像你和我这样的人缴纳更多的税，这样他们就可以从中窃取更多。如果这样做意味着完全透明并且每个人都将缴纳他们应得的税款，那将是一件好事，但老实说，这永远不会发生。腐败是印度政治中普遍存在的一件事，它超越了党派界限。
You say as if any government has ever done anything to curb corruption and tax evasion. They want people like you and me to pay more tax so that they can steal more from it. If doing this means there will be complete transparency and everyone will pay their fair share of taxes, then it would be good but let's be honest that is never going to happen. Corruption is one thing that is universal in Indian politics, which goes beyond party lines.
你说得好像哪一届政府曾为遏制腐败和逃税做过什么似的。他们希望像你和我这样的人缴纳更多的税，这样他们就可以从中窃取更多。如果这样做意味着完全透明并且每个人都将缴纳他们应得的税款，那将是一件好事，但老实说，这永远不会发生。腐败是印度政治中普遍存在的一件事，它超越了党派界限。
FortunatelyGrowing
If it curbs corruption and tax evasion, our policy makers don't make it
如果这真的能遏制腐败和逃税，我们的政策制定者就不会去制定它了
If it curbs corruption and tax evasion, our policy makers don't make it
如果这真的能遏制腐败和逃税，我们的政策制定者就不会去制定它了
Sad_Use_642
if the govt knows where i am spending my money if it's able to curb corruption and tax evasion.
if this what govt. wants then why don't bjp govt. make amendments in electoral polls, why are they hiding their source of donation
“如果政府能够遏制腐败和逃税，我不介意政府知道我把钱花在哪里了。”
如果这就是政府想要的，那么为什么BJP政府不对选举投票进行修正，为什么要隐藏他们的捐款来源？
if the govt knows where i am spending my money if it's able to curb corruption and tax evasion.
if this what govt. wants then why don't bjp govt. make amendments in electoral polls, why are they hiding their source of donation
“如果政府能够遏制腐败和逃税，我不介意政府知道我把钱花在哪里了。”
如果这就是政府想要的，那么为什么BJP政府不对选举投票进行修正，为什么要隐藏他们的捐款来源？
garlak63
Too much trust on the govt you're showing
对政府的信任度太高了
Too much trust on the govt you're showing
对政府的信任度太高了
Dry-Expert-2017
This fear is spreaded by politician. Banks and money launderers.
If there is great reset there is great revolution.. goverment comes and go.. stupidity always rules. Eventually one stupid leader will break all the system.
This poor people don't understand, digital money is for high value transaction. The reason being, ones rupees become digital indian goverment can't claim tax frauds , as they will exact information how and when money changed hands. So no more cash for vote and rallys. No more electoral bonds..
But this privacy advocate keeps doing the bidding for politicians and money launderers. Meanwhile forgetting every common person is at the mercy of goverment subsidy and infrastructure. Everything common men spends on, prices are set by government.
这种恐惧是由政客、银行和洗黑钱的人传播的。
如果有大重置，就会有大革命。政府来来去去，愚蠢的人总是统治者。最终，一个愚蠢的领导人会破坏所有的系统。
这些穷人不明白，数字货币是用于高价值的交易。原因是，如果卢比变成了数字货币，印度政府就不能声称有税务欺诈行为，因为他们会准确地知道钱是如何以及何时转手的。因此，不再有现金用于拉投票和集会。不再有选举债券...
但这位“隐私倡导者”一直在为政客和洗钱者鼓噪。同时忘记了每个普通人都受政府补贴和基础设施的帮助。普通人花的所有东西，价格都是由政府设定的。
This fear is spreaded by politician. Banks and money launderers.
If there is great reset there is great revolution.. goverment comes and go.. stupidity always rules. Eventually one stupid leader will break all the system.
This poor people don't understand, digital money is for high value transaction. The reason being, ones rupees become digital indian goverment can't claim tax frauds , as they will exact information how and when money changed hands. So no more cash for vote and rallys. No more electoral bonds..
But this privacy advocate keeps doing the bidding for politicians and money launderers. Meanwhile forgetting every common person is at the mercy of goverment subsidy and infrastructure. Everything common men spends on, prices are set by government.
这种恐惧是由政客、银行和洗黑钱的人传播的。
如果有大重置，就会有大革命。政府来来去去，愚蠢的人总是统治者。最终，一个愚蠢的领导人会破坏所有的系统。
这些穷人不明白，数字货币是用于高价值的交易。原因是，如果卢比变成了数字货币，印度政府就不能声称有税务欺诈行为，因为他们会准确地知道钱是如何以及何时转手的。因此，不再有现金用于拉投票和集会。不再有选举债券...
但这位“隐私倡导者”一直在为政客和洗钱者鼓噪。同时忘记了每个普通人都受政府补贴和基础设施的帮助。普通人花的所有东西，价格都是由政府设定的。
johnnybenign
The OP have such a detailed review of why the digital rupee is bad and you come up with a response like no wallet…what the OP posted is absolutely true and is one of the steps towards the New World Order.
OP对数字卢比的坏处进行了如此详细的评论，而你却作出了“不用带钱包”这样的回应......OP发布的内容绝对是真实的，是走向新世界秩序的步骤之一。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
The OP have such a detailed review of why the digital rupee is bad and you come up with a response like no wallet…what the OP posted is absolutely true and is one of the steps towards the New World Order.
OP对数字卢比的坏处进行了如此详细的评论，而你却作出了“不用带钱包”这样的回应......OP发布的内容绝对是真实的，是走向新世界秩序的步骤之一。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
legit_working
There’s nothing to hide if you haven’t done anything wrong, right?
如果你没有做错什么，就没有什么可隐瞒的，对不对？
There’s nothing to hide if you haven’t done anything wrong, right?
如果你没有做错什么，就没有什么可隐瞒的，对不对？
ArukaAravind
There is an assumption here that the government would be responsible with your personal data.
Would you really be comfortable with sponsoring an agenda (not illegal) which the then-present government opposes ? For example, what if you are sponsoring the opposition party, or you are making donations to a religious / casteist cause which the current government(I don't necessarily mean BJP; I am referring to any future government that may come) doesn't approve of ?
How do you ensure that the government doesnt screw you because it doesnt like where you are spending the money?
Why does government even need such a power ? Any reason that you provide such as tax evasion / illegal donations to banned organizations etc can be monitored by the government without this dangerous right. All the other governments in the world are doing it.
What we lack as always is the actual implementation of the existing laws. Not more power to the government.
这里有一个假设，即政府会对你的个人数据负责。
假如你赞助当时政府反对的议程（不违法），你真的会感到安心吗？例如，如果你赞助反对党，或者你向现任政府（我不一定是指印度人民党；我指的是未来可能出现的任何政府）不赞成的宗教/种姓主义事业捐款，那会如何？
你如何确保政府不会因为不喜欢你把钱花在哪里而坑害你？
政府为什么需要这样的权力？你提供的任何理由，如逃税/非法捐赠给被禁止的组织等，现在就可以被政府监控，而不需要这种危险的权利。世界上所有其他政府都是这样。
我们一直都缺乏的是对现有法律的实际执行。而不是给予政府更多的权力。
There is an assumption here that the government would be responsible with your personal data.
Would you really be comfortable with sponsoring an agenda (not illegal) which the then-present government opposes ? For example, what if you are sponsoring the opposition party, or you are making donations to a religious / casteist cause which the current government(I don't necessarily mean BJP; I am referring to any future government that may come) doesn't approve of ?
How do you ensure that the government doesnt screw you because it doesnt like where you are spending the money?
Why does government even need such a power ? Any reason that you provide such as tax evasion / illegal donations to banned organizations etc can be monitored by the government without this dangerous right. All the other governments in the world are doing it.
What we lack as always is the actual implementation of the existing laws. Not more power to the government.
这里有一个假设，即政府会对你的个人数据负责。
假如你赞助当时政府反对的议程（不违法），你真的会感到安心吗？例如，如果你赞助反对党，或者你向现任政府（我不一定是指印度人民党；我指的是未来可能出现的任何政府）不赞成的宗教/种姓主义事业捐款，那会如何？
你如何确保政府不会因为不喜欢你把钱花在哪里而坑害你？
政府为什么需要这样的权力？你提供的任何理由，如逃税/非法捐赠给被禁止的组织等，现在就可以被政府监控，而不需要这种危险的权利。世界上所有其他政府都是这样。
我们一直都缺乏的是对现有法律的实际执行。而不是给予政府更多的权力。
ARABfox246
So would you poop in public, since its not wrong?
那么你会在公共场合大便吗，因为它没有错？
So would you poop in public, since its not wrong?
那么你会在公共场合大便吗，因为它没有错？
CaptainMarble90
I totally agree with you. As a tax paying citizen (or rather someone who can’t avoid getting taxed) I’m totally in favour of this and will be using it as soon as it’s available. Only businesses who want to move money as they want will have problem with this. I don’t mind if they get screwed.
“对我来说，这听起来不错。”
我完全同意你的观点。作为一个纳税公民（或者更确切地说是无法避免被征税的人），我完全赞成这一做法，一旦它可用了，我就会立即使用它。只有那些想随心所欲地转移资金的企业才会对此有意见。我不介意这些人会感到不爽。
I totally agree with you. As a tax paying citizen (or rather someone who can’t avoid getting taxed) I’m totally in favour of this and will be using it as soon as it’s available. Only businesses who want to move money as they want will have problem with this. I don’t mind if they get screwed.
“对我来说，这听起来不错。”
我完全同意你的观点。作为一个纳税公民（或者更确切地说是无法避免被征税的人），我完全赞成这一做法，一旦它可用了，我就会立即使用它。只有那些想随心所欲地转移资金的企业才会对此有意见。我不介意这些人会感到不爽。
Kautilya0511
This is so stupid, just because digital rupee is introduced doesn't mean that paper currency will be stopped and coming to your worst scenarios:
Purpose lixed rupee for subsidies is actually good, then the farmer can't claim subsidy for something and use that money for something else, say farmer gets money to buy seeds then he can't spend it on booze
No employer will do that, if some braindead employer tries to do it no one will work for him
这真是太愚蠢了，数字卢比的推出并不意味着纸币将被停止，或者会出现你设想的最糟糕的情况：
1 将卢比与补贴的目的挂钩其实是好的，这样一来农民就不能为某些东西申请补贴却将这些钱用于其他方面，比如说农民拿到钱只能去买种子，那么他就不能把钱花在酒上了。
2 没有雇主会这样做，如果一些脑残的雇主试图这样做，没有人会为他工作。
This is so stupid, just because digital rupee is introduced doesn't mean that paper currency will be stopped and coming to your worst scenarios:
Purpose lixed rupee for subsidies is actually good, then the farmer can't claim subsidy for something and use that money for something else, say farmer gets money to buy seeds then he can't spend it on booze
No employer will do that, if some braindead employer tries to do it no one will work for him
这真是太愚蠢了，数字卢比的推出并不意味着纸币将被停止，或者会出现你设想的最糟糕的情况：
1 将卢比与补贴的目的挂钩其实是好的，这样一来农民就不能为某些东西申请补贴却将这些钱用于其他方面，比如说农民拿到钱只能去买种子，那么他就不能把钱花在酒上了。
2 没有雇主会这样做，如果一些脑残的雇主试图这样做，没有人会为他工作。
exorcis
OP
Yeah, just give 10 years and they will have you by your balls. FASTAG was initially optional.. now it is compulsory. They initially offer everything optional and when people get used to it they make it mandatory. And don’t think employers will not do this. All of them will do it. You won’t have any option to say no. Just like the Chinese people. Just wait.
对对，只要给10年时间，他们就会把你拿捏得死死地。FASTAG（注：在印度，Fastag是一种快速简便的支付过路费的方式）最初是可选的，现在是强制的。他们最初提供的都是可选的，当人们习惯了，他们就会把它变成强制性的。不要以为雇主不会这样做。所有的人都会这样做。你不会有任何选择说不。就像中国人一样。等着看吧。
OP
Yeah, just give 10 years and they will have you by your balls. FASTAG was initially optional.. now it is compulsory. They initially offer everything optional and when people get used to it they make it mandatory. And don’t think employers will not do this. All of them will do it. You won’t have any option to say no. Just like the Chinese people. Just wait.
对对，只要给10年时间，他们就会把你拿捏得死死地。FASTAG（注：在印度，Fastag是一种快速简便的支付过路费的方式）最初是可选的，现在是强制的。他们最初提供的都是可选的，当人们习惯了，他们就会把它变成强制性的。不要以为雇主不会这样做。所有的人都会这样做。你不会有任何选择说不。就像中国人一样。等着看吧。
KvK_07
Bruh fastag like systems are mandatory in most countries. And if the chip isn't available, then higher toll is collected. This is simple logic. If you can handle an automobile then you should be able to handle fastag
噗， fastag之类的系统在大多数国家都是强制性的。而且在这些国家如果没有芯片，还会收取更高的过路费。这是很简单的逻辑。如果你能驾驭汽车，那么你就应该能驾驭fastag。
Bruh fastag like systems are mandatory in most countries. And if the chip isn't available, then higher toll is collected. This is simple logic. If you can handle an automobile then you should be able to handle fastag
噗， fastag之类的系统在大多数国家都是强制性的。而且在这些国家如果没有芯片，还会收取更高的过路费。这是很简单的逻辑。如果你能驾驭汽车，那么你就应该能驾驭fastag。
the_running_stache
Exactly! OP, what’s your problem with fastag being made mandatory, besides your “government control” argument? Why do you still want people exchanging cash at toll plazas? That whole system leads to corruption, slows down the traffic lanes, which can further cause accidents, etc.
正是如此! OP，除了你的"政府控制"的论点外，你对fastag的强制使用有什么问题？为什么你仍然希望人们在收费站兑换现金？那个系统会导致腐败，堵塞交通，这可能会进一步导致事故，等等。
Exactly! OP, what’s your problem with fastag being made mandatory, besides your “government control” argument? Why do you still want people exchanging cash at toll plazas? That whole system leads to corruption, slows down the traffic lanes, which can further cause accidents, etc.
正是如此! OP，除了你的"政府控制"的论点外，你对fastag的强制使用有什么问题？为什么你仍然希望人们在收费站兑换现金？那个系统会导致腐败，堵塞交通，这可能会进一步导致事故，等等。
AryanEPH
op comes from a family which only deals with cash and evades taxes to be paid to the government.. now he is sweating by the new proposal
op来自一个只与现金打交道的家庭，并逃避向政府缴税，现在他对新提案感到很头疼
op comes from a family which only deals with cash and evades taxes to be paid to the government.. now he is sweating by the new proposal
op来自一个只与现金打交道的家庭，并逃避向政府缴税，现在他对新提案感到很头疼
Bruzgin
I see what you're saying, but why will we not have an option to say no? Unlike china, we are a Democracy. People can always protest.
我明白你的意思，但为什么我们不能选择说不呢？与中国不同，我们是一个民主国家。人们总是可以提出抗议。
I see what you're saying, but why will we not have an option to say no? Unlike china, we are a Democracy. People can always protest.
我明白你的意思，但为什么我们不能选择说不呢？与中国不同，我们是一个民主国家。人们总是可以提出抗议。
Living_Ice_6764
And that leads to where? A couple of sedition charges??
结果是什么？几个煽动性的指控？
And that leads to where? A couple of sedition charges??
结果是什么？几个煽动性的指控？
OkCrew9
Search for EZ pass on Google. It's mandatory in the USA since the 80s. This allows car tracking effectively. And this is a country which has the most number of 'freedom' protestors.
在谷歌上搜索一下“EZ pass”吧。这是自80年代以来在美国的强制性规定。这可以有效地追踪汽车。而这是一个拥有最多"自由"抗议者的国家。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Search for EZ pass on Google. It's mandatory in the USA since the 80s. This allows car tracking effectively. And this is a country which has the most number of 'freedom' protestors.
在谷歌上搜索一下“EZ pass”吧。这是自80年代以来在美国的强制性规定。这可以有效地追踪汽车。而这是一个拥有最多"自由"抗议者的国家。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Beautiful_Lack_8740
Do you even understand the concept of e-rupee or what?
Digital Rupee will exist only virtually. It has no physical form.
even the value of that piece of paper is set by rbi without that that paper value ll be less than 1 rupee.
You can’t withdraw it from bank in the form of physical currency notes.
the digital rupee is not even targeted for consumers but at banks .When you transfer using upi the consumer see his money has been transferred to another bank but in reality that bank has not got the money yet. It takes a week to transfer all the cash from one bank to different bank which adds up the cost.In case of digital rupee that wont be an issue.
The only way you can use it is by spending it virtually using an online system like UPI
again not targeted for consumers
Specific purpose digital rupee: Since everything is digital, govt now lixs money to specific purpose. This is already happening. Govt is planning to give urea subsidies to farmers as digital rupees which can only be used for urea purchase
Please give me a source where it tells that there will be a "specific purpose account and so on" where do u get those conspiracy theories xd
你根本不懂什么是数字卢比吧？
“数字卢比将只是虚拟存在。它没有实体形式。”
甚至那张纸的价值也是由RBI设定的，若非如此，那张纸的价值低于1卢比。
“你不能以实体纸币的形式从银行提取它。”
数字卢比甚至不是针对消费者的，而是针对银行的。当你用upi转账时，消费者看到他的钱已经转到了另一家银行，但实际上那家银行还没有拿到钱。把所有的现金从一家银行转到另一家银行需要一周的时间，这增加了成本，在使用数字卢比的情况下，这不会是一个问题。
“你可以使用它的唯一方法是通过使用UPI等在线系统进行虚拟消费。”
这也不是针对消费者的。
“数字卢比的特定用途。由于所有东西都是数字化的，政府现在将钱与特定用途联系起来。这已经在发生了。政府正计划将尿素补贴以数字卢比的形式发放给农民，只能用于购买尿素。”
请给我一个消息来源，它能告诉我将有一个"特定用途的账户等等"，你从哪里得到这些阴谋论的 xd
Do you even understand the concept of e-rupee or what?
Digital Rupee will exist only virtually. It has no physical form.
even the value of that piece of paper is set by rbi without that that paper value ll be less than 1 rupee.
You can’t withdraw it from bank in the form of physical currency notes.
the digital rupee is not even targeted for consumers but at banks .When you transfer using upi the consumer see his money has been transferred to another bank but in reality that bank has not got the money yet. It takes a week to transfer all the cash from one bank to different bank which adds up the cost.In case of digital rupee that wont be an issue.
The only way you can use it is by spending it virtually using an online system like UPI
again not targeted for consumers
Specific purpose digital rupee: Since everything is digital, govt now lixs money to specific purpose. This is already happening. Govt is planning to give urea subsidies to farmers as digital rupees which can only be used for urea purchase
Please give me a source where it tells that there will be a "specific purpose account and so on" where do u get those conspiracy theories xd
你根本不懂什么是数字卢比吧？
“数字卢比将只是虚拟存在。它没有实体形式。”
甚至那张纸的价值也是由RBI设定的，若非如此，那张纸的价值低于1卢比。
“你不能以实体纸币的形式从银行提取它。”
数字卢比甚至不是针对消费者的，而是针对银行的。当你用upi转账时，消费者看到他的钱已经转到了另一家银行，但实际上那家银行还没有拿到钱。把所有的现金从一家银行转到另一家银行需要一周的时间，这增加了成本，在使用数字卢比的情况下，这不会是一个问题。
“你可以使用它的唯一方法是通过使用UPI等在线系统进行虚拟消费。”
这也不是针对消费者的。
“数字卢比的特定用途。由于所有东西都是数字化的，政府现在将钱与特定用途联系起来。这已经在发生了。政府正计划将尿素补贴以数字卢比的形式发放给农民，只能用于购买尿素。”
请给我一个消息来源，它能告诉我将有一个"特定用途的账户等等"，你从哪里得到这些阴谋论的 xd
obliviousNick
This post needs to be reported as misinformation spreading.
这个帖子需要以传播错误信息被举报。
This post needs to be reported as misinformation spreading.
这个帖子需要以传播错误信息被举报。
pepper-sandwich
No, any form of opposition dialogue should be considered and proper response has to be made. Cancelling will never lead to a democratic society.
Also, these are all possibilities. You can never say this only applies to the banks and not consumers. First it will be applied to organisations and the banking sector, if it's successful it will be rolled out to consumers.
I'm not sure about the conspiracy theories of the great reset and Klaus rule, but let's be honest what are all the counter arguments that say these things will never ever happen? There were no promises made, the government didn't ask the public for their opinion.
不，任何形式的反对派的话都应该被考虑，并且必须做出适当的回应。“取消”永远不会产生一个民主社会。
另外，这些都是可能性。你永远不能说这只适用于银行而不适用于消费者。它首先会适用于组织和银行业，如果它是成功的，它将被推广到消费者。
我不清楚大重置和索罗斯的统治之类的阴谋论，但说实话，说这些事情永远不会发生的反驳论点是什么？没有做出任何承诺，政府也没有征求公众的意见。
No, any form of opposition dialogue should be considered and proper response has to be made. Cancelling will never lead to a democratic society.
Also, these are all possibilities. You can never say this only applies to the banks and not consumers. First it will be applied to organisations and the banking sector, if it's successful it will be rolled out to consumers.
I'm not sure about the conspiracy theories of the great reset and Klaus rule, but let's be honest what are all the counter arguments that say these things will never ever happen? There were no promises made, the government didn't ask the public for their opinion.
不，任何形式的反对派的话都应该被考虑，并且必须做出适当的回应。“取消”永远不会产生一个民主社会。
另外，这些都是可能性。你永远不能说这只适用于银行而不适用于消费者。它首先会适用于组织和银行业，如果它是成功的，它将被推广到消费者。
我不清楚大重置和索罗斯的统治之类的阴谋论，但说实话，说这些事情永远不会发生的反驳论点是什么？没有做出任何承诺，政府也没有征求公众的意见。
obliviousNick
No, any form of opposition dialogue should be considered and proper response has to be made. Cancelling will never lead to a democratic society.
It doesn't work everytime. Look at CAA and farm law protests. They didn't care for a proper response to some misinformation. India is too volatile to wait for someone to clear out misinformation and no chance everyone will even believe that person.
“不，任何形式的反对派的话都应该被考虑，并且必须做出适当的回应。“取消”永远不会产生一个民主社会。”
这不是每次都起效的。看看 CAA和对农业法的抗议活动。这些人不关心对一些错误信息的适当回应。印度太不稳定了，等不及有人清除错误信息，甚至不可能每个人都会相信那个出来辟谣的人。
No, any form of opposition dialogue should be considered and proper response has to be made. Cancelling will never lead to a democratic society.
It doesn't work everytime. Look at CAA and farm law protests. They didn't care for a proper response to some misinformation. India is too volatile to wait for someone to clear out misinformation and no chance everyone will even believe that person.
“不，任何形式的反对派的话都应该被考虑，并且必须做出适当的回应。“取消”永远不会产生一个民主社会。”
这不是每次都起效的。看看 CAA和对农业法的抗议活动。这些人不关心对一些错误信息的适当回应。印度太不稳定了，等不及有人清除错误信息，甚至不可能每个人都会相信那个出来辟谣的人。
ShreyBY
Anything to do with Klaus Schwab is not to our interest as a country, and even more so when it comes to our civilization. He hates the individual countries, and wants the world to be a single Empire he and his thugs can control.
I believe in Modi. Doesn't mean I must support every move he makes.
And fuc the WEF
与克劳斯-施瓦布有关的任何事情都不符合我们国家的利益，涉及到我们的文明时更是如此。他憎恨各个国家，并希望世界成为他和他的暴徒们可以控制的单一帝国。
我相信莫迪。但这并不意味着我必须支持他的每一步行动。
还有，去他的世界经济论坛
Anything to do with Klaus Schwab is not to our interest as a country, and even more so when it comes to our civilization. He hates the individual countries, and wants the world to be a single Empire he and his thugs can control.
I believe in Modi. Doesn't mean I must support every move he makes.
And fuc the WEF
与克劳斯-施瓦布有关的任何事情都不符合我们国家的利益，涉及到我们的文明时更是如此。他憎恨各个国家，并希望世界成为他和他的暴徒们可以控制的单一帝国。
我相信莫迪。但这并不意味着我必须支持他的每一步行动。
还有，去他的世界经济论坛
exorcis
OP
Correct
正确的
OP
Correct
正确的
Sumeetxagrawal
As someone who grew up around several small businesses, india has a whole parallel cash economy that is just as big if not bigger than the digital/accounted for economy. This parallel cash economy is what keeps small business alive since it sets people free from govt intervention and whenever there has been a recession CASH HAS SAVED OUR ECONOMY since it acts as a cushion to the falling asset prices (especially real estate). Now, I think a lot of the panic about digital rupee is misplaced. Maybe what OP fears will be true 70 years from now, but certainly not today. The digital rupee mostly just helps the banks have instant clearing of transactions instead of doing it in batches like they do for UPI. Maybe for salaried employees it might one day become a problem with the independence of spending and accounting, but right now you can still withdraw your salary money as cash. I would say to not worry as the crores of businessmen around india will never let something like that happen lmao. What OP essentially fears is the complete doing away of "personal drawings" as an excuse which I understand can be scary since there wouldn't be any privacy anymore, but I don't think something like completely un-withdrawable salaries are gonna be a thing anytime soon.
作为一个在几个小企业周围长大的人，我想说印度有一个完整的平行现金经济，即使不比数字/会计经济大，也至少一样大。这种平行的现金经济使小企业得以生存，因为它使人们摆脱了政府的干预，每当出现经济衰退时，现金就会拯救我们的经济，因为它对资产价格的下跌（尤其是房地产）起到了缓冲作用。现在，我认为很多关于数字卢比的恐慌是错误的。也许OP担心的事情在70年后会成为现实，但肯定不是今天。数字卢比主要是帮助银行对交易进行即时结算，而不是像UPI那样分批进行。也许对于受薪雇员来说，随着消费和会计的独立，有一天它可能会成为一个问题，但现在你仍然可以把你的工资钱作为现金提取出来。我想说的是，不要担心，因为印度成千上万的商人绝不会让这样的事情发生，笑。OP本质上担心的是完全取消"个人提款"，我理解这可能是可怕的，因为不再有任何隐私，但我不认为像完全不可提取的工资很快就会成为事实。
As someone who grew up around several small businesses, india has a whole parallel cash economy that is just as big if not bigger than the digital/accounted for economy. This parallel cash economy is what keeps small business alive since it sets people free from govt intervention and whenever there has been a recession CASH HAS SAVED OUR ECONOMY since it acts as a cushion to the falling asset prices (especially real estate). Now, I think a lot of the panic about digital rupee is misplaced. Maybe what OP fears will be true 70 years from now, but certainly not today. The digital rupee mostly just helps the banks have instant clearing of transactions instead of doing it in batches like they do for UPI. Maybe for salaried employees it might one day become a problem with the independence of spending and accounting, but right now you can still withdraw your salary money as cash. I would say to not worry as the crores of businessmen around india will never let something like that happen lmao. What OP essentially fears is the complete doing away of "personal drawings" as an excuse which I understand can be scary since there wouldn't be any privacy anymore, but I don't think something like completely un-withdrawable salaries are gonna be a thing anytime soon.
作为一个在几个小企业周围长大的人，我想说印度有一个完整的平行现金经济，即使不比数字/会计经济大，也至少一样大。这种平行的现金经济使小企业得以生存，因为它使人们摆脱了政府的干预，每当出现经济衰退时，现金就会拯救我们的经济，因为它对资产价格的下跌（尤其是房地产）起到了缓冲作用。现在，我认为很多关于数字卢比的恐慌是错误的。也许OP担心的事情在70年后会成为现实，但肯定不是今天。数字卢比主要是帮助银行对交易进行即时结算，而不是像UPI那样分批进行。也许对于受薪雇员来说，随着消费和会计的独立，有一天它可能会成为一个问题，但现在你仍然可以把你的工资钱作为现金提取出来。我想说的是，不要担心，因为印度成千上万的商人绝不会让这样的事情发生，笑。OP本质上担心的是完全取消"个人提款"，我理解这可能是可怕的，因为不再有任何隐私，但我不认为像完全不可提取的工资很快就会成为事实。
DesiBail
OP, there are multiple things.
India economy is bigger but not all are paying taxes. We need taxes from hospitals to military and everything else.
At the same time your concern is also correct. If government gets too much information babudom becomes a bigger problem.
Right now saving our borders is bigger priority than concern of privacy from government, even if i don't like govt to know everything.
in current situation Indian government is the lesser evil
but that can change anytime.
So powerless people are screwed from all sides.
OP，我们面临的情况太复杂了。
印度的经济规模较大，但并非所有人都在缴税。我们需要税收，从医院到军队和其他一切。
同时，你的担心也是正确的。如果政府获得了太多的信息，政府权力会成为一个更大的问题。
现在，拯救我们的边界比关注政府获取隐私更重要，即使我不喜欢政府知道一切。
在目前的情况下，印度政府是一个较小的邪恶。
但这种情况随时可能改变。
因此，无权无势的人从各方面都受到了伤害。
OP, there are multiple things.
India economy is bigger but not all are paying taxes. We need taxes from hospitals to military and everything else.
At the same time your concern is also correct. If government gets too much information babudom becomes a bigger problem.
Right now saving our borders is bigger priority than concern of privacy from government, even if i don't like govt to know everything.
in current situation Indian government is the lesser evil
but that can change anytime.
So powerless people are screwed from all sides.
OP，我们面临的情况太复杂了。
印度的经济规模较大，但并非所有人都在缴税。我们需要税收，从医院到军队和其他一切。
同时，你的担心也是正确的。如果政府获得了太多的信息，政府权力会成为一个更大的问题。
现在，拯救我们的边界比关注政府获取隐私更重要，即使我不喜欢政府知道一切。
在目前的情况下，印度政府是一个较小的邪恶。
但这种情况随时可能改变。
因此，无权无势的人从各方面都受到了伤害。
Material_Detective59
It will not replace traditional currency rather will co exist similar to ola money paytm money etc. stop fear mongering
它不会取代传统的货币，而是会共同存在，类似于OLA币、Paytm币等。停止散布恐惧
It will not replace traditional currency rather will co exist similar to ola money paytm money etc. stop fear mongering
它不会取代传统的货币，而是会共同存在，类似于OLA币、Paytm币等。停止散布恐惧
exorcis
OP
It’s not fear mongering. This is not Modi’s plan but it is happening on a Global level. Once everything is digital, all it takes is a flick of switch to stop you from doing certain activities. China has already implemented this, America and Europe are implementing soon and now India is on that same path of total financial control. I support Modi on other issues but here there are global forces at play. Cannot support this
这不是散播恐惧。这不只是莫迪的计划，而是正在全球范围内发生。一旦所有的东西都是数字化的，只需轻轻一按开关就能阻止你做某些活动。中国已经实施了这一点，美国和欧洲很快就会实施，现在印度也走上了全面金融控制的道路。我在其他问题上支持莫迪，但这次里面有全球力量在发挥作用。我不支持这个。
OP
It’s not fear mongering. This is not Modi’s plan but it is happening on a Global level. Once everything is digital, all it takes is a flick of switch to stop you from doing certain activities. China has already implemented this, America and Europe are implementing soon and now India is on that same path of total financial control. I support Modi on other issues but here there are global forces at play. Cannot support this
这不是散播恐惧。这不只是莫迪的计划，而是正在全球范围内发生。一旦所有的东西都是数字化的，只需轻轻一按开关就能阻止你做某些活动。中国已经实施了这一点，美国和欧洲很快就会实施，现在印度也走上了全面金融控制的道路。我在其他问题上支持莫迪，但这次里面有全球力量在发挥作用。我不支持这个。
KvK_07
If all the govts conspire together, they can even make physical cash worthless in a minute. Cash is nothing but a promise
如果所有政府一起密谋，他们甚至可以在一分钟内使实物现金变得一文不值。现金只不过是一种承诺
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
If all the govts conspire together, they can even make physical cash worthless in a minute. Cash is nothing but a promise
如果所有政府一起密谋，他们甚至可以在一分钟内使实物现金变得一文不值。现金只不过是一种承诺
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Plastic-Philosopher5
This is same line of thinking that pulled down Farm laws and fuelled CAA protests.
All based on assumptions. Imagine this, now imagine that, now imagine worse of that. Also imaging everyone will be sitting with their eyes and ears closed while all of this, that and other things happens.
Currently the e rupee is being introduced with motto to use blockchain to introduce a digital currency that has legal tender status. Also, it is being introduced to make purpose specific welfare scheme money transfer possible, which will reduce leakage to huge extent.
Your concerns regarding government monitoring your expenditure is already possible via UPI. Use cash if you don’t want to be monitored. There are specific cases where monitoring is desired. As stated: welfare schemes, ngo’s, fundraisers. These causes can use this tech to great help.
Regarding companies providing salaries purpose-lixed: literal facepalm speculation. We don’t live in a dystopia yet.
这个帖子很像当初推倒农场法和助长CAA抗议的思路。
所有这些都基于假设。“你们想象一下这个”，“现在再想象一下那个”，“现在想象一下更糟糕的情况”。同时又假设，在所有这些、那些和其他事情发生时，每个人都会闭着眼睛和捂着耳朵坐着。
目前，电子卢比正在被引入，其目的是使用区块链来引入具有法定货币地位的数字货币。此外，它的推出是为了使特定目的的福利计划资金转移成为可能，这将在很大程度上减少纰漏。
你那些对政府监控你的支出的担忧，政府目前已经可以通过UPI实现。如果你不想被监控，请使用现金。有一些特定的情况是需要监控的。如前所述：福利计划、非政府组织、募捐者。这些事业可以利用这项技术获得很大帮助。
关于公司提供与目的相联系的工资：完全是无稽之谈。我们还没有生活在一个反乌托邦里。
This is same line of thinking that pulled down Farm laws and fuelled CAA protests.
All based on assumptions. Imagine this, now imagine that, now imagine worse of that. Also imaging everyone will be sitting with their eyes and ears closed while all of this, that and other things happens.
Currently the e rupee is being introduced with motto to use blockchain to introduce a digital currency that has legal tender status. Also, it is being introduced to make purpose specific welfare scheme money transfer possible, which will reduce leakage to huge extent.
Your concerns regarding government monitoring your expenditure is already possible via UPI. Use cash if you don’t want to be monitored. There are specific cases where monitoring is desired. As stated: welfare schemes, ngo’s, fundraisers. These causes can use this tech to great help.
Regarding companies providing salaries purpose-lixed: literal facepalm speculation. We don’t live in a dystopia yet.
这个帖子很像当初推倒农场法和助长CAA抗议的思路。
所有这些都基于假设。“你们想象一下这个”，“现在再想象一下那个”，“现在想象一下更糟糕的情况”。同时又假设，在所有这些、那些和其他事情发生时，每个人都会闭着眼睛和捂着耳朵坐着。
目前，电子卢比正在被引入，其目的是使用区块链来引入具有法定货币地位的数字货币。此外，它的推出是为了使特定目的的福利计划资金转移成为可能，这将在很大程度上减少纰漏。
你那些对政府监控你的支出的担忧，政府目前已经可以通过UPI实现。如果你不想被监控，请使用现金。有一些特定的情况是需要监控的。如前所述：福利计划、非政府组织、募捐者。这些事业可以利用这项技术获得很大帮助。
关于公司提供与目的相联系的工资：完全是无稽之谈。我们还没有生活在一个反乌托邦里。
很赞 1
收藏