印度人民买卖每件物品都要向政府纳税，他们还为自己的工资缴纳税金。为什么中国人不用这么做？
正文翻译
@Kanthaswamy Balasubramaniam
Independent Legal Banking Consultant at Self-Employment14h
Every Nation or at least more than four fifth of the world's countries tax their citizens right?
Unless you are really wealthy and have very few Citizens like Qatar, you can't help it. You have to tax people.
Tax is inevitable
The Problem in India is that India is Corrupt and Dirty
So your Taxes go into a lot of junk including a worthless City in Andhra Pradesh and a lot of greedy corrupt pockets in Bihar
You ultimately get nothing for your taxes
If you see the taxes paid in percentage, people in Europe pay a large chunk in taxes and in Scandinavia you have even 55%–60% paid in taxes
Yet those people get plent of benefits like free healthcare and free education and unemployment benefits
每个国家或者至少世界上五分之四以上的国家都对其公民征税，对吗？
除非你真的很富有，而且像卡塔尔一样，公民很少，否则你别无选择。你必须向人民征税。
税收不可避免
印度的问题是腐败和肮脏
所以你的税款流向了很多垃圾地方，包括安得拉邦一个毫无价值的城市和比哈尔邦很多贪婪的腐败分子的口袋
最终你什么也得不到
如果你按百分比来查看纳税情况，你会发现欧洲人缴纳的税款占了很大一部分，而在斯堪的纳维亚半岛，人们缴纳的税款甚至占了55%-60%。
然而，这些人得到了很多福利，比如免费医疗、免费教育和失业救济金
Let's forget all those western Nations and look at China
Chinese people pay quite a lot of tax
An Average Chinese household pays almost 43.44% of their income in taxes , direct plus indirect
The Average Indian Household only pays 31.79%
The problem is the Chinese get a lot of stuff for their taxes
Portion of their taxes returns to them after 55 through a State Pension for Life
Portion of their Taxes goes to state health insurance which ensures hospitalization for 90% diseases incurs an out of pocket of maximum 30% with no extra premium. Employer Insurance could reduce this to as low as 5%
Education is free for the first 9 years and a paltry 2000 RMB for the next 3 years
University Education is subsidized between 40% to 100% depending on the province plus 20 year interest free loans are granted for Tuition, Rooming & Food
Doctorate and Post Doctorate Studies are fully free and stipend is provided by the state in addition to any private stipends
The State funds a lot of research and development helping China with EV Batteries and other critical areas
The Average Indian Household gets nothing
Thats because our tax money is spent on :-
Interest payment for borrowed debts on worthless infrastructure
Money to encourage corruption
Appeasement
Paying basic bills
Feeding 80 Crore people in a Nation with 31 Crore officially poor people
When we get nothing, paying taxes seems pointless
So it's the system
Overhauling the gutter system is critical here
Otherwise the other solution is to go and be loyal to another country, one that rewards you better
让我们忘记那些西方国家，看看中国
中国人缴纳了相当多的税
中国家庭平均要缴纳近43.44%的收入税，包括直接税和间接税
印度家庭平均仅支付31.79%
问题是中国人通过纳税获得了很多东西
55岁以后，部分税款将通过终身国家养老金返还给他们
他们缴纳的税款中有一部分用于国家健康保险，这确保了90%的疾病住院费用自付额最高为30%，无需额外保费。雇主保险可以将这一比例降至5%
前9年教育免费，后3年仅需2000元人民币
大学教育补贴金额根据省份不同，从40%到100%不等，此外还提供20年免息学费、住宿和伙食贷款
博士和博士后研究完全免费，除私人津贴外，还由国家提供津贴
国家投入大量资金帮助中国研发电动汽车电池和其他关键领域
普通印度家庭一无所获
这是因为我们的税金被用在：
为毫无价值的基础设施借入的债务支付利息
用金钱来鼓励腐败
绥靖政策
支付基本账单
在一个官方公布贫困人口为3.1亿的国家，为8亿人提供食物
当我们一无所获时，纳税似乎毫无意义
这就是系统差别
彻底检修排水沟系统至关重要
否则，另一个解决方案就是去效忠另一个国家，一个能给你带来更好回报的国家
Independent Legal Banking Consultant at Self-Employment14h
Every Nation or at least more than four fifth of the world's countries tax their citizens right?
Unless you are really wealthy and have very few Citizens like Qatar, you can't help it. You have to tax people.
Tax is inevitable
The Problem in India is that India is Corrupt and Dirty
So your Taxes go into a lot of junk including a worthless City in Andhra Pradesh and a lot of greedy corrupt pockets in Bihar
You ultimately get nothing for your taxes
If you see the taxes paid in percentage, people in Europe pay a large chunk in taxes and in Scandinavia you have even 55%–60% paid in taxes
Yet those people get plent of benefits like free healthcare and free education and unemployment benefits
每个国家或者至少世界上五分之四以上的国家都对其公民征税，对吗？
除非你真的很富有，而且像卡塔尔一样，公民很少，否则你别无选择。你必须向人民征税。
税收不可避免
印度的问题是腐败和肮脏
所以你的税款流向了很多垃圾地方，包括安得拉邦一个毫无价值的城市和比哈尔邦很多贪婪的腐败分子的口袋
最终你什么也得不到
如果你按百分比来查看纳税情况，你会发现欧洲人缴纳的税款占了很大一部分，而在斯堪的纳维亚半岛，人们缴纳的税款甚至占了55%-60%。
然而，这些人得到了很多福利，比如免费医疗、免费教育和失业救济金
Let's forget all those western Nations and look at China
Chinese people pay quite a lot of tax
An Average Chinese household pays almost 43.44% of their income in taxes , direct plus indirect
The Average Indian Household only pays 31.79%
The problem is the Chinese get a lot of stuff for their taxes
Portion of their taxes returns to them after 55 through a State Pension for Life
Portion of their Taxes goes to state health insurance which ensures hospitalization for 90% diseases incurs an out of pocket of maximum 30% with no extra premium. Employer Insurance could reduce this to as low as 5%
Education is free for the first 9 years and a paltry 2000 RMB for the next 3 years
University Education is subsidized between 40% to 100% depending on the province plus 20 year interest free loans are granted for Tuition, Rooming & Food
Doctorate and Post Doctorate Studies are fully free and stipend is provided by the state in addition to any private stipends
The State funds a lot of research and development helping China with EV Batteries and other critical areas
The Average Indian Household gets nothing
Thats because our tax money is spent on :-
Interest payment for borrowed debts on worthless infrastructure
Money to encourage corruption
Appeasement
Paying basic bills
Feeding 80 Crore people in a Nation with 31 Crore officially poor people
When we get nothing, paying taxes seems pointless
So it's the system
Overhauling the gutter system is critical here
Otherwise the other solution is to go and be loyal to another country, one that rewards you better
让我们忘记那些西方国家，看看中国
中国人缴纳了相当多的税
中国家庭平均要缴纳近43.44%的收入税，包括直接税和间接税
印度家庭平均仅支付31.79%
问题是中国人通过纳税获得了很多东西
55岁以后，部分税款将通过终身国家养老金返还给他们
他们缴纳的税款中有一部分用于国家健康保险，这确保了90%的疾病住院费用自付额最高为30%，无需额外保费。雇主保险可以将这一比例降至5%
前9年教育免费，后3年仅需2000元人民币
大学教育补贴金额根据省份不同，从40%到100%不等，此外还提供20年免息学费、住宿和伙食贷款
博士和博士后研究完全免费，除私人津贴外，还由国家提供津贴
国家投入大量资金帮助中国研发电动汽车电池和其他关键领域
普通印度家庭一无所获
这是因为我们的税金被用在：
为毫无价值的基础设施借入的债务支付利息
用金钱来鼓励腐败
绥靖政策
支付基本账单
在一个官方公布贫困人口为3.1亿的国家，为8亿人提供食物
当我们一无所获时，纳税似乎毫无意义
这就是系统差别
彻底检修排水沟系统至关重要
否则，另一个解决方案就是去效忠另一个国家，一个能给你带来更好回报的国家
评论翻译
@Kanthaswamy Balasubramaniam
Independent Legal Banking Consultant at Self-Employment14h
Every Nation or at least more than four fifth of the world's countries tax their citizens right?
Unless you are really wealthy and have very few Citizens like Qatar, you can't help it. You have to tax people.
Tax is inevitable
The Problem in India is that India is Corrupt and Dirty
So your Taxes go into a lot of junk including a worthless City in Andhra Pradesh and a lot of greedy corrupt pockets in Bihar
You ultimately get nothing for your taxes
If you see the taxes paid in percentage, people in Europe pay a large chunk in taxes and in Scandinavia you have even 55%–60% paid in taxes
Yet those people get plent of benefits like free healthcare and free education and unemployment benefits
每个国家或者至少世界上五分之四以上的国家都对其公民征税，对吗？
除非你真的很富有，而且像卡塔尔一样，公民很少，否则你别无选择。你必须向人民征税。
税收不可避免
印度的问题是腐败和肮脏
所以你的税款流向了很多垃圾地方，包括安得拉邦一个毫无价值的城市和比哈尔邦很多贪婪的腐败分子的口袋
最终你什么也得不到
如果你按百分比来查看纳税情况，你会发现欧洲人缴纳的税款占了很大一部分，而在斯堪的纳维亚半岛，人们缴纳的税款甚至占了55%-60%。
然而，这些人得到了很多福利，比如免费医疗、免费教育和失业救济金
Let's forget all those western Nations and look at China
Chinese people pay quite a lot of tax
An Average Chinese household pays almost 43.44% of their income in taxes , direct plus indirect
The Average Indian Household only pays 31.79%
The problem is the Chinese get a lot of stuff for their taxes
Portion of their taxes returns to them after 55 through a State Pension for Life
Portion of their Taxes goes to state health insurance which ensures hospitalization for 90% diseases incurs an out of pocket of maximum 30% with no extra premium. Employer Insurance could reduce this to as low as 5%
Education is free for the first 9 years and a paltry 2000 RMB for the next 3 years
University Education is subsidized between 40% to 100% depending on the province plus 20 year interest free loans are granted for Tuition, Rooming & Food
Doctorate and Post Doctorate Studies are fully free and stipend is provided by the state in addition to any private stipends
The State funds a lot of research and development helping China with EV Batteries and other critical areas
The Average Indian Household gets nothing
Thats because our tax money is spent on :-
Interest payment for borrowed debts on worthless infrastructure
Money to encourage corruption
Appeasement
Paying basic bills
Feeding 80 Crore people in a Nation with 31 Crore officially poor people
When we get nothing, paying taxes seems pointless
So it's the system
Overhauling the gutter system is critical here
Otherwise the other solution is to go and be loyal to another country, one that rewards you better
让我们忘记那些西方国家，看看中国
中国人缴纳了相当多的税
中国家庭平均要缴纳近43.44%的收入税，包括直接税和间接税
印度家庭平均仅支付31.79%
问题是中国人通过纳税获得了很多东西
55岁以后，部分税款将通过终身国家养老金返还给他们
他们缴纳的税款中有一部分用于国家健康保险，这确保了90%的疾病住院费用自付额最高为30%，无需额外保费。雇主保险可以将这一比例降至5%
前9年教育免费，后3年仅需2000元人民币
大学教育补贴金额根据省份不同，从40%到100%不等，此外还提供20年免息学费、住宿和伙食贷款
博士和博士后研究完全免费，除私人津贴外，还由国家提供津贴
国家投入大量资金帮助中国研发电动汽车电池和其他关键领域
普通印度家庭一无所获
这是因为我们的税金被用在：
为毫无价值的基础设施借入的债务支付利息
用金钱来鼓励腐败
绥靖政策
支付基本账单
在一个官方公布贫困人口为3.1亿的国家，为8亿人提供食物
当我们一无所获时，纳税似乎毫无意义
这就是系统差别
彻底检修排水沟系统至关重要
否则，另一个解决方案就是去效忠另一个国家，一个能给你带来更好回报的国家
Independent Legal Banking Consultant at Self-Employment14h
Every Nation or at least more than four fifth of the world's countries tax their citizens right?
Unless you are really wealthy and have very few Citizens like Qatar, you can't help it. You have to tax people.
Tax is inevitable
The Problem in India is that India is Corrupt and Dirty
So your Taxes go into a lot of junk including a worthless City in Andhra Pradesh and a lot of greedy corrupt pockets in Bihar
You ultimately get nothing for your taxes
If you see the taxes paid in percentage, people in Europe pay a large chunk in taxes and in Scandinavia you have even 55%–60% paid in taxes
Yet those people get plent of benefits like free healthcare and free education and unemployment benefits
每个国家或者至少世界上五分之四以上的国家都对其公民征税，对吗？
除非你真的很富有，而且像卡塔尔一样，公民很少，否则你别无选择。你必须向人民征税。
税收不可避免
印度的问题是腐败和肮脏
所以你的税款流向了很多垃圾地方，包括安得拉邦一个毫无价值的城市和比哈尔邦很多贪婪的腐败分子的口袋
最终你什么也得不到
如果你按百分比来查看纳税情况，你会发现欧洲人缴纳的税款占了很大一部分，而在斯堪的纳维亚半岛，人们缴纳的税款甚至占了55%-60%。
然而，这些人得到了很多福利，比如免费医疗、免费教育和失业救济金
Let's forget all those western Nations and look at China
Chinese people pay quite a lot of tax
An Average Chinese household pays almost 43.44% of their income in taxes , direct plus indirect
The Average Indian Household only pays 31.79%
The problem is the Chinese get a lot of stuff for their taxes
Portion of their taxes returns to them after 55 through a State Pension for Life
Portion of their Taxes goes to state health insurance which ensures hospitalization for 90% diseases incurs an out of pocket of maximum 30% with no extra premium. Employer Insurance could reduce this to as low as 5%
Education is free for the first 9 years and a paltry 2000 RMB for the next 3 years
University Education is subsidized between 40% to 100% depending on the province plus 20 year interest free loans are granted for Tuition, Rooming & Food
Doctorate and Post Doctorate Studies are fully free and stipend is provided by the state in addition to any private stipends
The State funds a lot of research and development helping China with EV Batteries and other critical areas
The Average Indian Household gets nothing
Thats because our tax money is spent on :-
Interest payment for borrowed debts on worthless infrastructure
Money to encourage corruption
Appeasement
Paying basic bills
Feeding 80 Crore people in a Nation with 31 Crore officially poor people
When we get nothing, paying taxes seems pointless
So it's the system
Overhauling the gutter system is critical here
Otherwise the other solution is to go and be loyal to another country, one that rewards you better
让我们忘记那些西方国家，看看中国
中国人缴纳了相当多的税
中国家庭平均要缴纳近43.44%的收入税，包括直接税和间接税
印度家庭平均仅支付31.79%
问题是中国人通过纳税获得了很多东西
55岁以后，部分税款将通过终身国家养老金返还给他们
他们缴纳的税款中有一部分用于国家健康保险，这确保了90%的疾病住院费用自付额最高为30%，无需额外保费。雇主保险可以将这一比例降至5%
前9年教育免费，后3年仅需2000元人民币
大学教育补贴金额根据省份不同，从40%到100%不等，此外还提供20年免息学费、住宿和伙食贷款
博士和博士后研究完全免费，除私人津贴外，还由国家提供津贴
国家投入大量资金帮助中国研发电动汽车电池和其他关键领域
普通印度家庭一无所获
这是因为我们的税金被用在：
为毫无价值的基础设施借入的债务支付利息
用金钱来鼓励腐败
绥靖政策
支付基本账单
在一个官方公布贫困人口为3.1亿的国家，为8亿人提供食物
当我们一无所获时，纳税似乎毫无意义
这就是系统差别
彻底检修排水沟系统至关重要
否则，另一个解决方案就是去效忠另一个国家，一个能给你带来更好回报的国家
很赞 15
收藏