非洲最大经济体为何损失了50%的GDP？
正文翻译
评论翻译
@orboakin8074
As a Nigerian, I appreciate the obxtive coverage of my country from your video. Extra kudos for not simply using the "colonialism" excuse that so many other people (even here) tend to use. It's genuinely tragic how mismanaged it has become. From civil war and tribalism plaguing us to military dictatorships and economic mismanagement ruining our fragile nation. Even after returning to democracy, we still face corruption, MASSIVE insecurity, lack of infrastructure, and economic mismanagement. There are some things to be cautiously optimistic about. Our current government has finally ended the useless fuel subsidy program that was a huge drain on our economy for decades and they have been implementing several phases of economic and tax reforms to stabilize our inflation, diversify our economy, curb insecurity and chronic deficits and also to curb corruption. It's resulting in hardships but is also generating some positive results..
作为一名尼日利亚人，我很感激你们视频中对我国家的客观报道。特别感谢你们没有像很多人（甚至这里的人）那样简单地拿“殖民主义”做借口。尼日利亚如今的困境真是令人悲哀。从内战和部落主义困扰我们，到军事独裁和经济管理不善破坏了这个脆弱的国家。即使在恢复民主之后，我们依然面临腐败、大规模的不安全、基础设施缺乏和经济管理不善的问题。虽然如此，也有一些值得谨慎乐观的地方。我们目前的政府终于结束了那个多年来对我们经济造成巨大负担的无用燃油补贴计划，并且已经开始实施多阶段的经济和税收改革，以稳定通货膨胀、多元化经济、遏制不安全现象和长期赤字，同时也在打击腐败。虽然这些改革带来了困难，但也在产生一些积极的结果。
As a Nigerian, I appreciate the obxtive coverage of my country from your video. Extra kudos for not simply using the "colonialism" excuse that so many other people (even here) tend to use. It's genuinely tragic how mismanaged it has become. From civil war and tribalism plaguing us to military dictatorships and economic mismanagement ruining our fragile nation. Even after returning to democracy, we still face corruption, MASSIVE insecurity, lack of infrastructure, and economic mismanagement. There are some things to be cautiously optimistic about. Our current government has finally ended the useless fuel subsidy program that was a huge drain on our economy for decades and they have been implementing several phases of economic and tax reforms to stabilize our inflation, diversify our economy, curb insecurity and chronic deficits and also to curb corruption. It's resulting in hardships but is also generating some positive results..
作为一名尼日利亚人，我很感激你们视频中对我国家的客观报道。特别感谢你们没有像很多人（甚至这里的人）那样简单地拿“殖民主义”做借口。尼日利亚如今的困境真是令人悲哀。从内战和部落主义困扰我们，到军事独裁和经济管理不善破坏了这个脆弱的国家。即使在恢复民主之后，我们依然面临腐败、大规模的不安全、基础设施缺乏和经济管理不善的问题。虽然如此，也有一些值得谨慎乐观的地方。我们目前的政府终于结束了那个多年来对我们经济造成巨大负担的无用燃油补贴计划，并且已经开始实施多阶段的经济和税收改革，以稳定通货膨胀、多元化经济、遏制不安全现象和长期赤字，同时也在打击腐败。虽然这些改革带来了困难，但也在产生一些积极的结果。
@faraibee
I wonder why experts ignore tribalism when it comes to Africa. Botswana is mainly 1 tribe unlike Nigeria's dozens of tribes.
If you live in Africa you know how tribes play a big role
我不明白为什么专家们在谈论非洲时忽视了部落问题。博茨瓦纳主要是一个部落，而不像尼日利亚那样有几十个部落。
如果你生活在非洲，你就知道部落在其中扮演着多么重要的角色。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
I wonder why experts ignore tribalism when it comes to Africa. Botswana is mainly 1 tribe unlike Nigeria's dozens of tribes.
If you live in Africa you know how tribes play a big role
我不明白为什么专家们在谈论非洲时忽视了部落问题。博茨瓦纳主要是一个部落，而不像尼日利亚那样有几十个部落。
如果你生活在非洲，你就知道部落在其中扮演着多么重要的角色。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@hungo7720
Nigeria is an epitome of how mismanagement can seriously drag the entire economy down.
尼日利亚是一个典型的例子，展示了管理不善如何严重拖慢整个经济的步伐。
Nigeria is an epitome of how mismanagement can seriously drag the entire economy down.
尼日利亚是一个典型的例子，展示了管理不善如何严重拖慢整个经济的步伐。
@jaredspencer3304
I wish people in rich countries would stop infantilizing poor people. "Scamming was the only option to feed their families." What about all the millions and millions of Nigerians who somehow found a way to feed their families without resorting to crime? Being poor doesn't make you immune to morality, and poor people would be the first to tell you that.
我希望富裕国家的人们能停止将贫穷人群视为无知的存在。很多人说“诈骗是养家糊口的唯一选择”，那成千上万的尼日利亚人呢？他们找到了一种不诉诸犯罪就能养家糊口的方法。贫穷并不会让你对道德免疫，穷人会第一个告诉你这一点。
I wish people in rich countries would stop infantilizing poor people. "Scamming was the only option to feed their families." What about all the millions and millions of Nigerians who somehow found a way to feed their families without resorting to crime? Being poor doesn't make you immune to morality, and poor people would be the first to tell you that.
我希望富裕国家的人们能停止将贫穷人群视为无知的存在。很多人说“诈骗是养家糊口的唯一选择”，那成千上万的尼日利亚人呢？他们找到了一种不诉诸犯罪就能养家糊口的方法。贫穷并不会让你对道德免疫，穷人会第一个告诉你这一点。
@adeyiwunmi
The problem is directly related to recent Nobel winners theory that good institutions is what makes good economies
这个问题直接与最近诺贝尔获奖者的理论有关，他们认为好的经济体制源于良好的制度。
The problem is directly related to recent Nobel winners theory that good institutions is what makes good economies
这个问题直接与最近诺贝尔获奖者的理论有关，他们认为好的经济体制源于良好的制度。
@corvusglaive5769
You forgot to mention a very important point: currency depreciation. The naira has lost over 50% of its value in just one year.
你忘记提到一个非常重要的因素：货币贬值。奈拉在短短一年内就失去了超过50%的价值。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
You forgot to mention a very important point: currency depreciation. The naira has lost over 50% of its value in just one year.
你忘记提到一个非常重要的因素：货币贬值。奈拉在短短一年内就失去了超过50%的价值。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@segunajayi3594
Thanks fr covering my country Nigeria. Many things are wrong with the economy at the moment
感谢你们关注我的国家尼日利亚。目前经济有很多问题。
Thanks fr covering my country Nigeria. Many things are wrong with the economy at the moment
感谢你们关注我的国家尼日利亚。目前经济有很多问题。
@mikedaniel1771
It's not a "branding" problem when trust breaks down, it's about institutions
当信任崩溃时，这不是“品牌”问题，而是关于制度的问题。
It's not a "branding" problem when trust breaks down, it's about institutions
当信任崩溃时，这不是“品牌”问题，而是关于制度的问题。
@brayan8346
I started watching your videos during my Freshman year at Indiana University (Economics and Finance Major). You have been frequently quoted in business and non-business papers relating to Economics. Your videos have more reach than you might imagine. Thank you, keep the quality going.
我是在印第安纳大学大一时开始看你的视频的（经济学和金融专业）。你的观点在商业和非商业论文中被频繁引用。你的影响力远比你想象的要大。谢谢你，继续保持高质量内容！
I started watching your videos during my Freshman year at Indiana University (Economics and Finance Major). You have been frequently quoted in business and non-business papers relating to Economics. Your videos have more reach than you might imagine. Thank you, keep the quality going.
我是在印第安纳大学大一时开始看你的视频的（经济学和金融专业）。你的观点在商业和非商业论文中被频繁引用。你的影响力远比你想象的要大。谢谢你，继续保持高质量内容！
@thomas316
Nigeria isn't alone. From the late 90s to about 2015 developing countries were catching up to developed countries but over the last decade they've been falling behind again with a widening gap by most measures.
One thing I see is that developed countries are hoovering up young, talented people from developing countries. It seems obvious to me that if the young educated and entrepreneurial are leaving a country will not advance.
尼日利亚并不是唯一一个这样的问题。从90年代末到2015年，发展中国家在逐渐赶超发达国家，但在过去的十年里，这些国家再次落后，并且在大多数衡量标准上差距逐渐扩大。我认为一个明显的原因是，发达国家正在吸纳发展中国家的年轻人才。对我来说，很显然，如果年轻的受过教育和有创业精神的人才离开一个国家，那么这个国家是不会发展的。
Nigeria isn't alone. From the late 90s to about 2015 developing countries were catching up to developed countries but over the last decade they've been falling behind again with a widening gap by most measures.
One thing I see is that developed countries are hoovering up young, talented people from developing countries. It seems obvious to me that if the young educated and entrepreneurial are leaving a country will not advance.
尼日利亚并不是唯一一个这样的问题。从90年代末到2015年，发展中国家在逐渐赶超发达国家，但在过去的十年里，这些国家再次落后，并且在大多数衡量标准上差距逐渐扩大。我认为一个明显的原因是，发达国家正在吸纳发展中国家的年轻人才。对我来说，很显然，如果年轻的受过教育和有创业精神的人才离开一个国家，那么这个国家是不会发展的。
@CryingCroc.
I remember, back in the 80s, reading about Nigeria's political leaders clamoring for a permanent UN Security Council seat - stating Nigeria was ready to lend Africa's voice on the world stage. That was forty years ago. Sadly, the social-political-economic state of Nigeria (and Africa in general) have actually fallen even farther behind in these last forty years! One might argue that Nigeria was more advanced than China, India or Indonesia in multiple fronts back then - but today, these Asian countries are far more advanced - esp. China.
我记得在80年代的时候，读到尼日利亚的政治领导人争取联合国安理会常任理事国席位，他们表示尼日利亚准备在世界舞台上代表非洲发声。那已经是四十年前的事了。可悲的是，在过去的四十年里，尼日利亚（以及整个非洲）的社会、政治和经济状态其实变得更加落后了！可以说，当时尼日利亚在多个方面比中国、印度或印度尼西亚还要先进，但今天这些亚洲国家已经远远超过了尼日利亚，尤其是中国。
I remember, back in the 80s, reading about Nigeria's political leaders clamoring for a permanent UN Security Council seat - stating Nigeria was ready to lend Africa's voice on the world stage. That was forty years ago. Sadly, the social-political-economic state of Nigeria (and Africa in general) have actually fallen even farther behind in these last forty years! One might argue that Nigeria was more advanced than China, India or Indonesia in multiple fronts back then - but today, these Asian countries are far more advanced - esp. China.
我记得在80年代的时候，读到尼日利亚的政治领导人争取联合国安理会常任理事国席位，他们表示尼日利亚准备在世界舞台上代表非洲发声。那已经是四十年前的事了。可悲的是，在过去的四十年里，尼日利亚（以及整个非洲）的社会、政治和经济状态其实变得更加落后了！可以说，当时尼日利亚在多个方面比中国、印度或印度尼西亚还要先进，但今天这些亚洲国家已经远远超过了尼日利亚，尤其是中国。
@atownofbigheads
One of the main reasons between developed and developing countries is the inefficient governments. There is a level of corruption and bureaucracy in developed countries as well, but in poor and developing countries, the politicians and elites strip the country of all its resources for the highest bidder and the poor/middle class are left to fight for scraps.
发达国家和发展中国家之间的主要原因之一是低效的政府。发达国家也存在一定程度的腐败和官僚主义，但在贫穷和发展中国家，政客和精英们为了出价最高的人剥夺了国家的所有资源，而穷人/中产阶级只能为残羹剩饭而战。
One of the main reasons between developed and developing countries is the inefficient governments. There is a level of corruption and bureaucracy in developed countries as well, but in poor and developing countries, the politicians and elites strip the country of all its resources for the highest bidder and the poor/middle class are left to fight for scraps.
发达国家和发展中国家之间的主要原因之一是低效的政府。发达国家也存在一定程度的腐败和官僚主义，但在贫穷和发展中国家，政客和精英们为了出价最高的人剥夺了国家的所有资源，而穷人/中产阶级只能为残羹剩饭而战。
@mpumelelobeyers957
As a South African... How DRC and Nigeria isn't the richest country in the face of the world is SHOCKING to me
作为一个南非人……我真搞不懂，为什么刚果和尼日利亚不是世界上最富有的国家，真是令人震惊。
As a South African... How DRC and Nigeria isn't the richest country in the face of the world is SHOCKING to me
作为一个南非人……我真搞不懂，为什么刚果和尼日利亚不是世界上最富有的国家，真是令人震惊。
@timothyofor9321
To be honest to me the problem of nigeria is not primarily government or leaders to me it is the people as a whole their way of thinking behaviour and perspective on issues
老实说，我认为尼日利亚的问题不是主要出在政府或领导人身上，而是整个国家的人们，他们的思维方式、行为和对问题的看法。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
To be honest to me the problem of nigeria is not primarily government or leaders to me it is the people as a whole their way of thinking behaviour and perspective on issues
老实说，我认为尼日利亚的问题不是主要出在政府或领导人身上，而是整个国家的人们，他们的思维方式、行为和对问题的看法。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@Joker-no1uh
Nigeria has so much potential. If they could just get a few good leaders in a row. They could be not only the leading country in Africa but, among other world powers.
尼日利亚有如此大的潜力。如果他们能够连续几年拥有一些优秀的领导人，他们不仅可以成为非洲的领导国家，而且可以成为其他世界大国之一。
Nigeria has so much potential. If they could just get a few good leaders in a row. They could be not only the leading country in Africa but, among other world powers.
尼日利亚有如此大的潜力。如果他们能够连续几年拥有一些优秀的领导人，他们不仅可以成为非洲的领导国家，而且可以成为其他世界大国之一。
@olaade730
As a Nigerian thank you for this analysis. This is the best video on the Nigerian economy. Very non biased, non-judgmental and factual
作为一名尼日利亚人，感谢你对这个分析的评价。这是关于尼日利亚经济的最好视频，既客观又事实，完全没有偏见。
As a Nigerian thank you for this analysis. This is the best video on the Nigerian economy. Very non biased, non-judgmental and factual
作为一名尼日利亚人，感谢你对这个分析的评价。这是关于尼日利亚经济的最好视频，既客观又事实，完全没有偏见。
@SiddhantA_Balls
It went from 500B$+ in 2023 down to just around 250B$+ in 2024, so it did lost 50% of it's economy in one year, similar to Lebanon's situation across the 2010's.
2023年时经济规模超过5000亿美元，但到2024年已经降至2500亿美元左右，因此它在一年内失去了50%的经济规模，类似于黎巴嫩在2010年代的情况。
It went from 500B$+ in 2023 down to just around 250B$+ in 2024, so it did lost 50% of it's economy in one year, similar to Lebanon's situation across the 2010's.
2023年时经济规模超过5000亿美元，但到2024年已经降至2500亿美元左右，因此它在一年内失去了50%的经济规模，类似于黎巴嫩在2010年代的情况。
@wise5674
This was a good video. As a Nigerian economist, I must say you put a lot of things into the broader global context, which was helpful. There were some crucial things you omitted like the currency exchange rates, the recent economic reforms and the underperforming power sector. But no video is perfect and I still give you a B+.
这是一个很好的视频。作为一名尼日利亚经济学家，我必须说你把很多事情放在了更广阔的全球背景下，这很有帮助。不过，有一些重要的内容你没有提到，比如汇率、近期的经济改革和表现不佳的电力行业。但没有一个视频是完美的，我还是给你打B+。
This was a good video. As a Nigerian economist, I must say you put a lot of things into the broader global context, which was helpful. There were some crucial things you omitted like the currency exchange rates, the recent economic reforms and the underperforming power sector. But no video is perfect and I still give you a B+.
这是一个很好的视频。作为一名尼日利亚经济学家，我必须说你把很多事情放在了更广阔的全球背景下，这很有帮助。不过，有一些重要的内容你没有提到，比如汇率、近期的经济改革和表现不佳的电力行业。但没有一个视频是完美的，我还是给你打B+。
@leftofyaba
nigeria is in this state because of pervasive corruption and a general lack of accountability; however, its potential remains immense and undeniable. i am proud to be a nigerian but it breaks my heart to see so much wasted potential.
nevertheless, i still believe in a brighter future ahead. what we need are leaders who believe so too and are committed to empowering the country rather than exploiting it for personal gain.
尼日利亚之所以处于这种状态，是因为普遍存在的腐败和普遍缺乏问责制；然而，它的潜力仍然是巨大和不可否认的。我为自己是尼日利亚人而自豪，但看到如此多的潜力被浪费，确实让我心痛。尽管如此，我依然相信未来会更加光明。我们需要的是那些相信这个未来，并且致力于赋能国家而非利用国家为个人谋取私利的领导人。
nigeria is in this state because of pervasive corruption and a general lack of accountability; however, its potential remains immense and undeniable. i am proud to be a nigerian but it breaks my heart to see so much wasted potential.
nevertheless, i still believe in a brighter future ahead. what we need are leaders who believe so too and are committed to empowering the country rather than exploiting it for personal gain.
尼日利亚之所以处于这种状态，是因为普遍存在的腐败和普遍缺乏问责制；然而，它的潜力仍然是巨大和不可否认的。我为自己是尼日利亚人而自豪，但看到如此多的潜力被浪费，确实让我心痛。尽管如此，我依然相信未来会更加光明。我们需要的是那些相信这个未来，并且致力于赋能国家而非利用国家为个人谋取私利的领导人。
@mayank.9203
can you make the 'Economics explained leaderboard' permanently public in some way ? maybe a website or gdrive or any other way ? would really love to have access to the list whenever i want .
你能否将“经济学解释排行榜”永久公开？也许可以做成一个网站或共享文档，或者用其他方式？我真的很想随时访问这个列表。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
can you make the 'Economics explained leaderboard' permanently public in some way ? maybe a website or gdrive or any other way ? would really love to have access to the list whenever i want .
你能否将“经济学解释排行榜”永久公开？也许可以做成一个网站或共享文档，或者用其他方式？我真的很想随时访问这个列表。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@KeiNovak
Didn't Nigeria have some sort of extremely strict ForEx (USD) controls in place around 2015 or so?
I heard from a Nigerian friend back then that students were having to drop out or something because their parents suddenly couldn't remit (i.e. transfer funds for) their tuition.
Wouldn't that play a huge part in the lack of foreign investment, especially if the profits can't be taken out of the country due to the ForeEx restrictions?
尼日利亚不是在2015年左右实施了某种极其严格的外汇（美元）管制吗？
当时我从一个尼日利亚朋友那里听说，学生们不得不辍学，因为他们的父母突然无法为他们的学费汇款。
这难道不是导致缺乏外国投资的一个重要原因吗？特别是如果由于外汇限制，利润无法带出该国的话？
Didn't Nigeria have some sort of extremely strict ForEx (USD) controls in place around 2015 or so?
I heard from a Nigerian friend back then that students were having to drop out or something because their parents suddenly couldn't remit (i.e. transfer funds for) their tuition.
Wouldn't that play a huge part in the lack of foreign investment, especially if the profits can't be taken out of the country due to the ForeEx restrictions?
尼日利亚不是在2015年左右实施了某种极其严格的外汇（美元）管制吗？
当时我从一个尼日利亚朋友那里听说，学生们不得不辍学，因为他们的父母突然无法为他们的学费汇款。
这难道不是导致缺乏外国投资的一个重要原因吗？特别是如果由于外汇限制，利润无法带出该国的话？
@FinanceThroughTime
Nigeria is hidden African gem, it has enormous potential to rise and become one of the most economically growing countries, but they need to stabilize the Naira first and reduce dependence on oil by investing in other sectors more.
尼日利亚是一个隐藏的非洲宝石，具有巨大的潜力，能够成为经济增长最快的国家之一，但他们需要首先稳定奈拉（Naira）并减少对石油的依赖，更多投资其他行业。
Nigeria is hidden African gem, it has enormous potential to rise and become one of the most economically growing countries, but they need to stabilize the Naira first and reduce dependence on oil by investing in other sectors more.
尼日利亚是一个隐藏的非洲宝石，具有巨大的潜力，能够成为经济增长最快的国家之一，但他们需要首先稳定奈拉（Naira）并减少对石油的依赖，更多投资其他行业。
@KamikazeCommie501
I never actually thought the Nigerian Prince scam came from Nigeria. Why would you use your own country's name in a scam? I just thought scammers were using a well-known but still mysterious African country that had a monarchy.
我我从没想过尼日利亚王子骗局来自尼日利亚。为什么骗子要在骗局中使用自己国家的名字呢？我一直以为骗子只是利用了一个著名但仍然神秘的非洲国家，而且那个国家有君主制。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
I never actually thought the Nigerian Prince scam came from Nigeria. Why would you use your own country's name in a scam? I just thought scammers were using a well-known but still mysterious African country that had a monarchy.
我我从没想过尼日利亚王子骗局来自尼日利亚。为什么骗子要在骗局中使用自己国家的名字呢？我一直以为骗子只是利用了一个著名但仍然神秘的非洲国家，而且那个国家有君主制。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@ikeemmanuel
See how everything stated going down immediately a new political party took over the country since 2015, and yet many of the people still supports and keeps voting for the same party based on religion affiliation, political party and tribe. The country is just too divided among religion, tribes and region to grow as a nation.
看看自2015年新政党接管国家以来，所有情况都开始恶化，但仍有很多人根据宗教信仰、政党和部族支持并投票给同一个政党。这个国家在宗教、部族和地区之间的分裂太深，无法作为一个国家发展。
See how everything stated going down immediately a new political party took over the country since 2015, and yet many of the people still supports and keeps voting for the same party based on religion affiliation, political party and tribe. The country is just too divided among religion, tribes and region to grow as a nation.
看看自2015年新政党接管国家以来，所有情况都开始恶化，但仍有很多人根据宗教信仰、政党和部族支持并投票给同一个政党。这个国家在宗教、部族和地区之间的分裂太深，无法作为一个国家发展。
@gideonofori9649
For a moment I was expecting Ghana to be mentioned when I saw some clips with Ghana vehicle plate...
I think Ghana will be another interesting country to look at... considering it was one of the first countries to gain independence and a rollercoaster economy
我一度以为会提到加纳，当我看到有加纳车牌的片段时... 我认为加纳将是另一个值得关注的有趣国家……考虑到它是最早获得独立的国家之一，也是过山车式的经济
For a moment I was expecting Ghana to be mentioned when I saw some clips with Ghana vehicle plate...
I think Ghana will be another interesting country to look at... considering it was one of the first countries to gain independence and a rollercoaster economy
我一度以为会提到加纳，当我看到有加纳车牌的片段时... 我认为加纳将是另一个值得关注的有趣国家……考虑到它是最早获得独立的国家之一，也是过山车式的经济
@TrangleC
Apparently Nigeria's population is much smaller than reported. Regions get money from the central government on the basis of their population numbers, so they inflate those.
显然，尼日利亚的实际人口比报告的要少。各地区根据人口数量从中央政府获得资金，因此他们会虚报人口数字。
Apparently Nigeria's population is much smaller than reported. Regions get money from the central government on the basis of their population numbers, so they inflate those.
显然，尼日利亚的实际人口比报告的要少。各地区根据人口数量从中央政府获得资金，因此他们会虚报人口数字。
@amanuelnigatu9199
Can you do a video on Ethiopia? It is one of Africa’s biggest economies and has been one of the fastest growing for some time now. However, its been having a lot of economic turmoil as of late with inflation, regime change, and inner turmoil. I think it would make for a very interesting video to research and make!
你能做一个关于埃塞俄比亚的视频吗？它是非洲最大的经济体之一，一段时间以来一直是增长最快的经济体之一。然而，它最近经历了很多经济动荡，包括通货膨胀、政权更迭和内部动荡。我认为这将是一个非常有趣的视频研究和制作！
Can you do a video on Ethiopia? It is one of Africa’s biggest economies and has been one of the fastest growing for some time now. However, its been having a lot of economic turmoil as of late with inflation, regime change, and inner turmoil. I think it would make for a very interesting video to research and make!
你能做一个关于埃塞俄比亚的视频吗？它是非洲最大的经济体之一，一段时间以来一直是增长最快的经济体之一。然而，它最近经历了很多经济动荡，包括通货膨胀、政权更迭和内部动荡。我认为这将是一个非常有趣的视频研究和制作！
@doomer_to_boomer2402
Did the way the country was "put together by the British" lead to groups not wanting to leave their homelands? I can't help but think that would have been the case in any circumstances
这个国家是由英国“拼凑”起来的，这是否导致了各个群体不愿离开自己的家园？我忍不住认为在任何情况下都会出现这种情况。
Did the way the country was "put together by the British" lead to groups not wanting to leave their homelands? I can't help but think that would have been the case in any circumstances
这个国家是由英国“拼凑”起来的，这是否导致了各个群体不愿离开自己的家园？我忍不住认为在任何情况下都会出现这种情况。
@attentionuniversity1646
As a Nigerian American, I miss Nigeria so much, and I wish her all the best in economic recovery.
作为一名尼日利亚裔美国人，我非常想念尼日利亚，祝愿她在经济恢复方面一切顺利。
As a Nigerian American, I miss Nigeria so much, and I wish her all the best in economic recovery.
作为一名尼日利亚裔美国人，我非常想念尼日利亚，祝愿她在经济恢复方面一切顺利。
@toji_killua97
we need a economics explained video about Tunisia ASAP
我们需要尽快做一个关于突尼斯的经济解释视频。
we need a economics explained video about Tunisia ASAP
我们需要尽快做一个关于突尼斯的经济解释视频。
@christopherwebber3804
Does Nigeria's capital still have a water treatment plant that isn't connected to anything, and therefore there is no running water available anywhere in the city? Yes, a water supply but no pipes.
尼日利亚的首都是否还有一个与任何东西都没有连接的水处理厂，因此在城市的任何地方都没有自来水可用？是的，有供水系统，但没有管道。
Does Nigeria's capital still have a water treatment plant that isn't connected to anything, and therefore there is no running water available anywhere in the city? Yes, a water supply but no pipes.
尼日利亚的首都是否还有一个与任何东西都没有连接的水处理厂，因此在城市的任何地方都没有自来水可用？是的，有供水系统，但没有管道。
@JustinOlpompa
Simple as this; bad leadership. The moment Nigeria gets a good leader, everything will turn around. It has the systems in place for a good leader to make the changes he needs, but theres no one who will make those changes.
事情很简单；糟糕的领导。一旦尼日利亚有了一个好领导，一切都会改变。尼日利亚已经具备了让一个好领导做出改变的系统，但问题是没有人能做出这些改变。
Simple as this; bad leadership. The moment Nigeria gets a good leader, everything will turn around. It has the systems in place for a good leader to make the changes he needs, but theres no one who will make those changes.
事情很简单；糟糕的领导。一旦尼日利亚有了一个好领导，一切都会改变。尼日利亚已经具备了让一个好领导做出改变的系统，但问题是没有人能做出这些改变。
@davidanalyst671
you didn't give a lot of reasons for the 50% drop. just a loss of image. Okay, but Wagner is in the neighborhood too, did you look that up?
你没有给出50%下降的很多原因。就说是形象受损，好吧，但瓦格纳也在附近，你有查过吗？
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
you didn't give a lot of reasons for the 50% drop. just a loss of image. Okay, but Wagner is in the neighborhood too, did you look that up?
你没有给出50%下降的很多原因。就说是形象受损，好吧，但瓦格纳也在附近，你有查过吗？
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@solomonokoli212
It's insane how their economy is now smaller than Scotland, Finland, or even the Czech Republic, especially as almost every financial institution in the 2010s predicted a trillion-dollar GDP for Nigeria by 2030. With South Africa also struggling and in terrible decline, perhaps Egypt can now claim the title of the African 'Superpower.'
他们现在的经济规模比苏格兰、芬兰甚至捷克共和国都要小，这太疯狂了，尤其是在2010年代，几乎所有金融机构都预测尼日利亚到2030年的GDP将达到1万亿美元。随着南非也在苦苦挣扎并陷入可怕的衰退，也许埃及现在可以宣称非洲“超级大国”的称号。
It's insane how their economy is now smaller than Scotland, Finland, or even the Czech Republic, especially as almost every financial institution in the 2010s predicted a trillion-dollar GDP for Nigeria by 2030. With South Africa also struggling and in terrible decline, perhaps Egypt can now claim the title of the African 'Superpower.'
他们现在的经济规模比苏格兰、芬兰甚至捷克共和国都要小，这太疯狂了，尤其是在2010年代，几乎所有金融机构都预测尼日利亚到2030年的GDP将达到1万亿美元。随着南非也在苦苦挣扎并陷入可怕的衰退，也许埃及现在可以宣称非洲“超级大国”的称号。
@rayrayray5911
Finally!!! I've been waiting for this video since 2018
终于来了！！！我从2018年开始就一直在等待这个视频。
Finally!!! I've been waiting for this video since 2018
终于来了！！！我从2018年开始就一直在等待这个视频。
@janeisklar3923
Bro, as a European I hoped and thought many African countries, especially Nigeria and DR Congo, will slowly grow into strong and wealthy countries. Instead the entire continent is destabilising. It really breaks my heart. This continent and the people of Africa just don't seem to get a break...
兄弟，作为一名欧洲人，我曾希望并认为许多非洲国家，特别是尼日利亚和刚果民主共和国，会逐渐发展成强大而富裕的国家。结果，整个大陆却在不稳定。这真让我心碎。这个大陆和非洲人民似乎永远得不到喘息的机会...
Bro, as a European I hoped and thought many African countries, especially Nigeria and DR Congo, will slowly grow into strong and wealthy countries. Instead the entire continent is destabilising. It really breaks my heart. This continent and the people of Africa just don't seem to get a break...
兄弟，作为一名欧洲人，我曾希望并认为许多非洲国家，特别是尼日利亚和刚果民主共和国，会逐渐发展成强大而富裕的国家。结果，整个大陆却在不稳定。这真让我心碎。这个大陆和非洲人民似乎永远得不到喘息的机会...
@judeike5660
Nigeria didn't lose 50% of its real GDP. It only lost GDP when measured in $USD because of over 200% duation of the local currency that drastically increased the exchange rate.
尼日利亚并没有失去50%的实际GDP。它只是因为本地货币贬值超过200%，导致以美元衡量时GDP下降，汇率大幅上涨。
Nigeria didn't lose 50% of its real GDP. It only lost GDP when measured in $USD because of over 200% duation of the local currency that drastically increased the exchange rate.
尼日利亚并没有失去50%的实际GDP。它只是因为本地货币贬值超过200%，导致以美元衡量时GDP下降，汇率大幅上涨。
@LearningNeverStopsEX
Finally!!!! People are analysing our failed economy. I've gotten tired of watching other nations being analysed while I lived in one dying fast and no one seemed to care.
终于来了！！！人们终于开始分析我们失败的经济了。我已经厌倦了看到其他国家的经济被分析，而我却生活在一个快速衰退的国家，似乎没有人关心。
Finally!!!! People are analysing our failed economy. I've gotten tired of watching other nations being analysed while I lived in one dying fast and no one seemed to care.
终于来了！！！人们终于开始分析我们失败的经济了。我已经厌倦了看到其他国家的经济被分析，而我却生活在一个快速衰退的国家，似乎没有人关心。
@Nazdravetikva
Branding can be very important for foreign investment to start flowing into a country. I’m from a country always called the poorest in the EU, every story in the news is about Corruption, political instability or miserable living standards for the poorest. Despite a favourable business climate, it struggles to get investment
品牌对于外国投资开始流入一个国家非常重要。我来自一个一直被称为欧盟最贫穷的国家，新闻里的每一个故事都是关于腐败、政治不稳定或最贫困人口悲惨的生活水平。尽管商业环境有利，但它很难吸引投资
Branding can be very important for foreign investment to start flowing into a country. I’m from a country always called the poorest in the EU, every story in the news is about Corruption, political instability or miserable living standards for the poorest. Despite a favourable business climate, it struggles to get investment
品牌对于外国投资开始流入一个国家非常重要。我来自一个一直被称为欧盟最贫穷的国家，新闻里的每一个故事都是关于腐败、政治不稳定或最贫困人口悲惨的生活水平。尽管商业环境有利，但它很难吸引投资
@thomasbetts01
Europe is not the only place like this. The difficulties that have arisen in the current generation are heartbreaking. I wanted to know how to spend some money that I had. I utilised a portion of it for my e-commerce venture, however it failed. I'm considering my options for investing the remaining funds, but I'm not really sure which path to go.
欧洲并不是唯一存在这种情况的地方。目前一代人面临的困难令人心碎。我曾想知道如何使用我所拥有的一些资金，我用一部分资金投资了我的电子商务项目，但失败了。我在考虑如何投资剩余的资金，但我并不确定该走哪条路。
Europe is not the only place like this. The difficulties that have arisen in the current generation are heartbreaking. I wanted to know how to spend some money that I had. I utilised a portion of it for my e-commerce venture, however it failed. I'm considering my options for investing the remaining funds, but I'm not really sure which path to go.
欧洲并不是唯一存在这种情况的地方。目前一代人面临的困难令人心碎。我曾想知道如何使用我所拥有的一些资金，我用一部分资金投资了我的电子商务项目，但失败了。我在考虑如何投资剩余的资金，但我并不确定该走哪条路。
@davianoinglesias5030
Nigeria would be at par with South Africa were it not for the crescent moon and star people in Northern Nigeria
如果不是北尼日利亚的月亮与星星标志的人，尼日利亚本应与南非平起平坐。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Nigeria would be at par with South Africa were it not for the crescent moon and star people in Northern Nigeria
如果不是北尼日利亚的月亮与星星标志的人，尼日利亚本应与南非平起平坐。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
@richardkeyen199
Oil has been the greatest curse for us as a nation, no other sector has been able to thrive due to our over reliance on it, let's not even discuss the high level of corruption. Regardless we are resilient and would never give up striving for a better Nigeria
石油一直是我们国家最大的诅咒，由于我们对石油的过度依赖，没有其他行业能够蓬勃发展，更不用说高水平的腐败了。无论如何，我们都很有韧性，永远不会放弃为一个更好的尼日利亚而奋斗
Oil has been the greatest curse for us as a nation, no other sector has been able to thrive due to our over reliance on it, let's not even discuss the high level of corruption. Regardless we are resilient and would never give up striving for a better Nigeria
石油一直是我们国家最大的诅咒，由于我们对石油的过度依赖，没有其他行业能够蓬勃发展，更不用说高水平的腐败了。无论如何，我们都很有韧性，永远不会放弃为一个更好的尼日利亚而奋斗
@thefalsehero
This is no surprise to anyone with enough reasoning skill and historical knowledge.
Demographics is destiny.
对于任何有足够推理能力和历史知识的人来说，这并不令人惊讶。
人口结构决定命运。
This is no surprise to anyone with enough reasoning skill and historical knowledge.
Demographics is destiny.
对于任何有足够推理能力和历史知识的人来说，这并不令人惊讶。
人口结构决定命运。
@jontalbot1
I know this is slightly off point but as a UK academic l supervised a Nigerian student writing a dissertation on public health provision in Nigeria. When l looked at the level of provision it was way behind countries with a similar GDP and pretty much the worst rates of infant mortality in the world, among other indicators. Another Nigerian student, true to form, tried to scam me ( and other staff).
我知道这有些偏离主题，但作为一名英国学者，我曾指导过一位尼日利亚学生写关于尼日利亚公共卫生服务的论文。当我查看该国的公共卫生水平时，发现其远远落后于其他GDP相似的国家，并且在世界上拥有最糟糕的婴儿死亡率等指标。另一位尼日利亚学生，典型的做法，是试图诈骗我（以及其他工作人员）。
I know this is slightly off point but as a UK academic l supervised a Nigerian student writing a dissertation on public health provision in Nigeria. When l looked at the level of provision it was way behind countries with a similar GDP and pretty much the worst rates of infant mortality in the world, among other indicators. Another Nigerian student, true to form, tried to scam me ( and other staff).
我知道这有些偏离主题，但作为一名英国学者，我曾指导过一位尼日利亚学生写关于尼日利亚公共卫生服务的论文。当我查看该国的公共卫生水平时，发现其远远落后于其他GDP相似的国家，并且在世界上拥有最糟糕的婴儿死亡率等指标。另一位尼日利亚学生，典型的做法，是试图诈骗我（以及其他工作人员）。
natefoster5454
I've heard of stories where some petrol refinery security officers were bribed. And then that group would then tank out some of the oil and sell it on the black market. It's good for them in the short run, but utterly awful for them in the long run.
我听说过一些炼油厂保安人员被贿赂的故事。然后，这个组织会把一些石油储存起来，在黑市上出售。从短期来看，这对他们有好处，但从长远来看，这对他们来说是非常糟糕的。
I've heard of stories where some petrol refinery security officers were bribed. And then that group would then tank out some of the oil and sell it on the black market. It's good for them in the short run, but utterly awful for them in the long run.
我听说过一些炼油厂保安人员被贿赂的故事。然后，这个组织会把一些石油储存起来，在黑市上出售。从短期来看，这对他们有好处，但从长远来看，这对他们来说是非常糟糕的。
@oquaika-qua3043
I assure you the problem in Nigeria isn’t branding. It’s the institutions within the country itself. Nigeria has weak institutions that is susceptible to whomever is in power. The growth in the early 21st century was simply because those in power were not completely callous and had a brain on their head. Even with the corruption they were able to get things done. Since 2014, they have brought in a military leader with a track record of not understanding basic economics; and subsequently a wanton criminal and his cronies. With the already weak institutions, anyone with a bit of clairvoyance can tell you that is a recipe for disaster.
我敢保证，尼日利亚的问题不是品牌建设。问题出在该国的制度上。尼日利亚的制度很脆弱，容易受到掌权者的影响。21世纪初的增长仅仅是因为当时的领导人并非完全冷酷无情，且有一定智慧。即便在腐败的情况下，他们也能把事情做好。但自2014年以来，尼日利亚引入了一位缺乏基本经济学理解的军事领导人，随后又有了一个无能的罪犯及其亲信。面对已经薄弱的制度，任何具备一些洞察力的人都能看出，这简直是灾难的配方。
I assure you the problem in Nigeria isn’t branding. It’s the institutions within the country itself. Nigeria has weak institutions that is susceptible to whomever is in power. The growth in the early 21st century was simply because those in power were not completely callous and had a brain on their head. Even with the corruption they were able to get things done. Since 2014, they have brought in a military leader with a track record of not understanding basic economics; and subsequently a wanton criminal and his cronies. With the already weak institutions, anyone with a bit of clairvoyance can tell you that is a recipe for disaster.
我敢保证，尼日利亚的问题不是品牌建设。问题出在该国的制度上。尼日利亚的制度很脆弱，容易受到掌权者的影响。21世纪初的增长仅仅是因为当时的领导人并非完全冷酷无情，且有一定智慧。即便在腐败的情况下，他们也能把事情做好。但自2014年以来，尼日利亚引入了一位缺乏基本经济学理解的军事领导人，随后又有了一个无能的罪犯及其亲信。面对已经薄弱的制度，任何具备一些洞察力的人都能看出，这简直是灾难的配方。
@atypicalafrican
Apart from a few errors on the maps, this is an extremely fair assesment with zero political propaganda
除了地图上有一些小错误外，这的确是一个非常公正的评估，没有任何政治宣传。
Apart from a few errors on the maps, this is an extremely fair assesment with zero political propaganda
除了地图上有一些小错误外，这的确是一个非常公正的评估，没有任何政治宣传。
@balerikirmu.11
North is the food basket of Nigeria!
Grains, beans, and animals are moved from north to south.
北方是尼日利亚的粮仓！粮食、豆类和牲畜从北方运往南方。
North is the food basket of Nigeria!
Grains, beans, and animals are moved from north to south.
北方是尼日利亚的粮仓！粮食、豆类和牲畜从北方运往南方。
@dannyarcher6370
It always vexes me that the people who say that Africa's development was hamstrung by colonialists arbitrarily drawing borders forcing different ethnic groups together are the same people who advocate for multiculturalism and tolerance in the West.
每次听到那些说非洲发展受制于殖民者随意划定边界，把不同民族强行捆绑在一起的人，恰恰是那些在西方倡导多元文化和宽容的人，我就觉得很恼火。
It always vexes me that the people who say that Africa's development was hamstrung by colonialists arbitrarily drawing borders forcing different ethnic groups together are the same people who advocate for multiculturalism and tolerance in the West.
每次听到那些说非洲发展受制于殖民者随意划定边界，把不同民族强行捆绑在一起的人，恰恰是那些在西方倡导多元文化和宽容的人，我就觉得很恼火。
@nathanngumi8467
No condition is permanent. The West African coast from Liberia to Nigeria will become the most vibrant economic zone in the world this century.
没有什么情况是永恒的。21世纪， 从利比里亚到尼日利亚的西非沿海地区将成为世界上最具活力的经济区。
No condition is permanent. The West African coast from Liberia to Nigeria will become the most vibrant economic zone in the world this century.
没有什么情况是永恒的。21世纪， 从利比里亚到尼日利亚的西非沿海地区将成为世界上最具活力的经济区。
@chipcook5346
Didn't economists tell us that Nigeria will have a billion people and a world power? Of course, they did. Are you sure colonialism is at fault here? The cultures were there before the English. The cultures are still there after the English are gone. Culture is fate. Ask South Africa.
难道经济学家没有告诉我们尼日利亚将有十亿人口，成为世界强国吗？当然，他们说过。你确定殖民主义是罪魁祸首吗？这些文化在英国人到来之前就存在了，英国人离开后这些文化依然存在。文化决定命运。问问南非就知道了。
Didn't economists tell us that Nigeria will have a billion people and a world power? Of course, they did. Are you sure colonialism is at fault here? The cultures were there before the English. The cultures are still there after the English are gone. Culture is fate. Ask South Africa.
难道经济学家没有告诉我们尼日利亚将有十亿人口，成为世界强国吗？当然，他们说过。你确定殖民主义是罪魁祸首吗？这些文化在英国人到来之前就存在了，英国人离开后这些文化依然存在。文化决定命运。问问南非就知道了。
@Mr.Howell-jn5gy
Nigeria is like Argentina it is geographically and economically blessed and positioned. Argentina progress has been meddled with by America and also poor political choices. But Nigeria has no excuse. They are squandering it.
尼日利亚就像阿根廷一样，地理和经济上都非常有利。阿根廷的进步受到了美国的干涉，也受到了糟糕的政治选择的影响。但尼日利亚没有任何借口，他们正在浪费这个机会。
Nigeria is like Argentina it is geographically and economically blessed and positioned. Argentina progress has been meddled with by America and also poor political choices. But Nigeria has no excuse. They are squandering it.
尼日利亚就像阿根廷一样，地理和经济上都非常有利。阿根廷的进步受到了美国的干涉，也受到了糟糕的政治选择的影响。但尼日利亚没有任何借口，他们正在浪费这个机会。
@qhaweteyise1955
That first statement said it all. Nigeria provides a potential that all the other regions around it can grow.
第一句话说得很对。尼日利亚提供的潜力可以让周边所有地区都能成长。
That first statement said it all. Nigeria provides a potential that all the other regions around it can grow.
第一句话说得很对。尼日利亚提供的潜力可以让周边所有地区都能成长。
@Artemio-derose
Most rich people stay rich by spending like the poor and investing without stopping then most poor people stay poor by spending like the rich yet not investing like the rich but impressing them. People prefer to spend money on liabilities, Rather than investing in assets and be very profitable
大多数富人之所以能保持富有，是因为像穷人一样消费，不断投资；而大多数穷人之所以保持贫穷，是因为像富人一样消费，却不像富人那样投资，而是试图给富人留下印象。人们更倾向于花钱在负担上，而不是投资资产，从而实现更高的利润。
Most rich people stay rich by spending like the poor and investing without stopping then most poor people stay poor by spending like the rich yet not investing like the rich but impressing them. People prefer to spend money on liabilities, Rather than investing in assets and be very profitable
大多数富人之所以能保持富有，是因为像穷人一样消费，不断投资；而大多数穷人之所以保持贫穷，是因为像富人一样消费，却不像富人那样投资，而是试图给富人留下印象。人们更倾向于花钱在负担上，而不是投资资产，从而实现更高的利润。
@DragonwolfoftheSands
No mention of the end of the oil subsidy and no mention of insurgency in the oil producing region or why it exists
Because you would have suggested the former and can't explain how to avoid the latter
没有提到取消石油补贴，也没有提到石油生产地区的叛乱或为什么会存在叛乱。因为你可能会建议前者，却无法解释如何避免后者。
No mention of the end of the oil subsidy and no mention of insurgency in the oil producing region or why it exists
Because you would have suggested the former and can't explain how to avoid the latter
没有提到取消石油补贴，也没有提到石油生产地区的叛乱或为什么会存在叛乱。因为你可能会建议前者，却无法解释如何避免后者。
@FlintIronstag23
Nigeria needs to get its population growth under control if it wants better long-term prosperity. It has been predicted by 2050 Nigeria could become the third most populous country on Earth while only being the 32nd largest in terms of land area.
如果尼日利亚想要更好的长期繁荣，它需要控制人口增长。有人预测，到2050年，尼日利亚可能会成为世界第三大人口国，而在陆地面积上仅排名第32。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Nigeria needs to get its population growth under control if it wants better long-term prosperity. It has been predicted by 2050 Nigeria could become the third most populous country on Earth while only being the 32nd largest in terms of land area.
如果尼日利亚想要更好的长期繁荣，它需要控制人口增长。有人预测，到2050年，尼日利亚可能会成为世界第三大人口国，而在陆地面积上仅排名第32。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
很赞 11
收藏