龙腾网

为什么美国要从韩国撤除其萨德导弹防护罩?

大号儿童 2247
正文翻译

For years, a THAAD missile battery in Seongju County was South Korea's insurance policy against North Korea. But as war rages in West Asia, the US appears to be moving those defenses where they're needed most urgently — leaving Seoul exposed. The timing couldn't be worse. North Korea has just test-fired another cruise missile, watched personally by Kim Jong-un, as US-South Korea military drills get underway. What does this mean for Seoul? Palki Sharma tells you.
 
多年来,位于韩国庆州市的萨德(THAAD)导弹防御系统一直是韩国防御朝鲜的保险政策。但随着西亚战争的爆发,美国似乎正在将这些防御系统转移到最急需的地方——这使得首尔暴露在危险之中。时机再糟糕不过了。朝鲜刚刚进行了一次新的巡航导弹试射,金正恩亲自观摩,而美韩联合军事演习也已经开始。这对首尔意味着什么?帕尔基·夏尔马为您解读。
 
评论翻译
@Philip-Tank
THAAD system has been battle proven to be nothing but a piece of crap in the middle East! What a joke!

萨德系统在中东已经被实战证明只是垃圾!真是个笑话!

@seneelopilane5661
South Korea just learn that Iran defend itself by destroying military base from nirghboring countries

韩国才刚明白,伊朗是通过摧毁邻国的军事基地来保卫自己的。

@darlayjones669
In other words, South Korea just found out that Israel is US favorite child.

换句话说,韩国才发现以色列是美国的宠儿。

@davidhoward1113
Man imagine a united Korea! They would be a treat to any global power.

想象一下,如果朝鲜半岛统一,那将对任何全球大国都是一大挑战。

@mannogroneg1248
Just imagine a $20,000 drone is all it takes to destroy a $500,000,000 defense system, that will definitely give them something to think about.

想象一下,一架价值2万美元的无人机就能摧毁一个价值5亿美元的防御系统,这肯定会让他们深思。

@patecar20
South Korea needs to find a new massive reserve of oil, then they will get all the protection they need.

韩国需要找到一个新的大型石油储备,这样他们就能得到所有需要的保护。

@cory3900
South Korea has a better system and it shows in UAE against iran

韩国有更好的系统,这在阿联酋对抗伊朗时就体现出来了。

@stenstrup100
If I was Canada this would make me buy Swedish Grippen Fighters instead of F-35 from the USA.

如果我是加拿大,这会让我买瑞典的“鹰狮”战斗机,而不是美国的F-35。

@userer23hhccyiyfiugiutf
i thought iran has no more launcers so why they need more Thaad system

我以为伊朗已经没有发射器了,那他们为什么还需要更多的萨德系统?

@themossworld966
South Korea should know they are being used. They are moving it to the Middle East in unknown location but the world is watching closely.

韩国应该知道自己正在被利用。他们把萨德系统移到中东的未知地点,但全世界都在密切关注。

@Jaydanakim
South Korea already developed their own capabilities including missiles defence Europe, the Middle East and south East Asian are now buying defence product from them.

韩国已经发展出了自己的防御能力,包括导弹防御系统,欧洲、中东和东南亚现在都在从他们那里购买防御产品。

@lorditachi-4
This is a sign that the Iranian war is draining the USA

这是伊朗战争正在消耗美国的信号。

@kibakiemmanuel1917
After destroying them in West Asia, those too will meet the same fate

在西亚摧毁它们之后,那些国家也将面临相同的命运。

@zaknzri
Those countries having thaad now know what mistake they has made by paying for thaad lol

那些现在拥有萨德系统的国家知道他们通过支付萨德系统犯了什么错误,哈哈。

@jessenelson8106
I doubt China would allow another war on the Korean Peninsula, especially now that both sides have nukes.

我怀疑中国会允许朝鲜半岛发生另一场战争,尤其是在双方都有核武器的情况下。

@KotihariprasadaraoMuppana
America creating tensions around the world and doing arms business very well and the people suffered a lot of no peace of mind

美国在全世界制造紧张局势,做着武器生意,而人民则承受了很多,无法安宁。

@Bulaguy679
Well they didn't want it in the first place so now they got what they wanted

他们一开始就不想要这个,现在他们得到了他们想要的。

@sunilkumarnair5873
All foolish countries depend on US , this US will betray these fools any time. The country must understand how much to depend on the US, with each country money the US is becoming this big goon, is it not?

所有依赖美国的国家都是愚蠢的,这个美国随时会背叛这些傻瓜。国家必须明白,应该在多大程度上依赖美国,凭借每个国家的钱,美国正变得越来越像一个大恶棍,不是吗?

@what_was_your_dream
Maybe its a distraction or to make believe someone that its remove while in reality may be not?

也许这只是个分散注意力的手段,或者是让某些人相信它被移除了,但实际上可能并没有?

@HighLights-p4f1v
Seoul is a top exporter of defense systems proven and tested many times, thaad is not a loss

首尔是防御系统的顶级出口国,经过多次验证和测试,萨德系统并不算损失。

@valkaire100
They removed it because South Korea had their own..

他们移除了萨德系统,因为韩国有自己的防御系统。

@2026-h8s
After Iran, it became clear to everyone that missiles aren't the most important thing. The most important thing is having 200 fighter jets in the air, armed with missiles and electronic warfare systems.
If a country doesn't have an air force, it will lose.

在伊朗之后,每个人都清楚了,导弹并不是最重要的。最重要的是拥有200架战斗机在空中,配备导弹和电子战系统。如果一个国家没有空军,它就会失败。

@rogerfaint499
With or without THAAD, it's the same since THAADs are so useless in intercepting missiles.

有萨德和没有萨德一样,因为萨德在拦截导弹方面根本没用。

@johnsmalley6483
The DPRK has no interest in attacks on South Korea., with or without the American missile defense system.
The DPRK is a peaceful country that only wants to live in peace, but needs to have a nuclear weapons system for defense, and defense only.

朝鲜对攻击韩国不感兴趣,无论有没有美国的导弹防御系统。朝鲜是一个和平的国家,只希望和平生活,但需要拥有核武器系统来进行防卫,仅此而已。

@Charlotte-xe4rv
This is the US way of escalating the war by broadening the playing field...by removing this critical protection the exposure of this country's vulnerability is open to the neighboring enemy awaiting an opportunity to strike.. i just pray they wont take the baitand help US in this war to take down the north.. this war need to cease not escalate

这是美国通过扩大战场来升级战争的方式……通过移除这个关键的防护措施,暴露了这个国家的脆弱性,邻国的敌人正等待机会发动攻击。我只祈祷他们不要上当,帮助美国在这场战争中打败北方。这个战争应该停止,而不是升级。

@inspomax250
I salute the determination and resilience of Iranian people. Amazing how they gave the USA & Israel a tough battle. Interceptors almost depleted

我敬佩伊朗人民的决心和韧性。令人惊讶的是,他们让美国和以色列付出了艰难的代价。拦截系统几乎耗尽。

@zacklee5168
If I was China or Russia, I would have supplied Iran with all the weapon they need just to fuck and deplete the american and israelis stockpile. Putin is a puss!! this is the perfect chance to get back at the american for supplying weapon to Ukraine!!

如果我是中国或俄罗斯,我会向伊朗提供所有他们需要的武器,只为削弱并耗尽美国和以色列的武器库存。普京真是个废物!这是报复美国向乌克兰提供武器的完美机会!

@EsmondFFrench
Isreal is more important
America ceates the division that comes with insecurity then sells security/ weapons
What a strategy....the white man divide the same race of people and then profits

以色列更重要。
美国制造不安全感带来的分裂,然后出售安全/武器。真是个策略……白人分化同一个种族的人,然后从中获利。

@williamchoi6902
Don't think America power like before. America dreams iran war over down to weak as Venezuela.

别以为美国像以前那样强大。美国梦想中的伊朗战争结束后,会像委内瑞拉一样衰弱。

@ParisSan01
North Korea isn’t much of a threat even if they shoot missiles because that’s all they can do. Nothing else will happen after that.

即使朝鲜发射导弹,也不算大威胁,因为那是他们唯一能做的事。之后不会发生其他事情。

@SDperspective
Kim should take note to what's going on in Iran, being a communist country!!

金正恩应该注意伊朗正在发生的事情,毕竟他们也是一个共产主义国家!

@JBear-in1ql
It’s a scam, South Korea never needed the THAAD. Peace now can roll in and eventually reunification can happen.

这是个骗局,韩国根本不需要萨德系统。现在可以迎来和平,最终实现统一。

@Chika-x2o5m
I think it is better for South Korea to foster a healthy relationship with their brothers North Korea. Ukraine should do the same with Russia. Taiwan should do the same with China. All of them allowing USA to deceive them should use middles east as example. American defences don't work... Iran proofed it.

我认为韩国最好与他们的“兄弟”朝鲜建立健康关系。乌克兰也应该与俄罗斯一样。台湾(地区)也应该与中国一样。他们都被美国欺骗的话,应该以中东为例。美国的防御系统不起作用……伊朗已经证明了这一点。

@drex6476
North Korea doesn't have to fire a single projectile. Just be patient and in another 50 years, there won't be any young people left in South Korea (given a fertility rate of only 0.72). Then Supreme leader's people can just walk across the border and take over South Korea

朝鲜根本不需要发射任何导弹。只要耐心再等50年,韩国就不会有年轻人了(考虑到生育率只有0.72)。那时,最高领导人的人民就可以直接穿越边境,占领韩国。

@SEEMASHARMA-gp7us
Beacuse US is pulling out its assets embassies and troops from everywhere. No more world policing. It will restrict its influence to Americas. No more paisa

因为美国正在从各地撤出资产、大使馆和军队。不再是世界警察。它会把影响力限制在美洲。不再有钱赚了。

@amit65226
South Korea should take the lesson as now Kim has good option to hit SK.
US government is opportunitisc friend and not a real friend,

韩国应该从中吸取教训,因为现在金正恩有了攻击韩国的好机会。
美国政府是机会主义的朋友,并不是真正的朋友。

@kek-g4e
If man understands what awaits him in eternity without salvation of christ Jesus, all strength should have been channeled towards seeking the good of others and not war, naked we came and shall return with nothing, either heaven or hell fire. Repent now is the acceptable time.

如果人们明白没有基督耶稣救赎,永恒等待他们的是什么,那么所有的力量都应该用于追求他人的福祉,而不是战争。赤身而来,空手而去,无论是天堂还是地狱之火。现在悔改是可接受的时机。

@tango10920
Or is it USA’s strategy to incite NK to jump into a conflict and stretch it to the other end of the world. Dept of War works not to stop wars but to fight more of them across the world. After all USA borders remain untouched

或者这是美国的策略,激怒朝鲜跳入冲突,并将战争延伸到世界另一端。战争部的工作不是阻止战争,而是让战争在世界各地继续进行。毕竟,美国本土的边界依然安全。

@7silk892
Well the United States Is Creating a Permanent Base . Iran is down to Practically just Drones and fumes

好吧,美国正在建立一个永久基地。伊朗几乎只剩下无人机和烟雾了。

@Myviewonly740
South Korea, Japan and the Philippines should learn a lesson from the Middle East.
Take a look at the countries that are hosting US military bases in the Middle East.
They will become the first target to be bombarded in the first time of a war.

韩国、日本和菲律宾应该从中东吸取教训。看看那些在中东 host 美国军事基地的国家。它们会成为战争开始时首当其冲的轰炸目标。

@MikeHeeney-k8i
Now North Korea embassy is missiled and totally destroyed things get harder

现在朝鲜的大使馆被导弹袭击,完全被摧毁,情况变得更加困难。

@raloed.363
So America has alot of bases around the world, means alot of stockpile of its weapons. So if when numbers start running low in war zone, migrate stockpile from other bases with lower risk. By time the overall depletion becomes a problem, the war machine is already running and manufacturing more than needed...

所以美国在世界各地有很多军事基地,这意味着它的武器储备量很大。因此,当战争区域的库存开始减少时,可以从其他风险较低的基地转移库存。当总体消耗成为问题时,战争机器已经在运转并制造出超过需求的武器……

@vlakiturah
should urge the freedom to people of north korean ...

应该呼吁朝鲜人民的自由……

@jase298hkhk
The system doesn't work on any drones or missiles that can change trajectory, and missiles that can change trajectory were invented in the 90s. So removing this useless piece of garbage will probably have no impact. It was explained by Ted Postal, a professor at MIT.

这个系统对任何能够改变轨迹的无人机或导弹都不起作用,而能改变轨迹的导弹是在90年代发明的。所以移除这个没用的东西可能不会产生什么影响。MIT的教授Ted Postal曾解释过这个问题。

@koykix11
Where's the Indian voiceover guy? Did you fire him?

印度的配音员去哪了?你们解雇他了吗?

@차주식-t9h
Korea is not worried. Korea has developed its own l-sam defense system. This missile has better accuracy and range than Shad. Also, the UAE is deploying Cheongung-2 with an interception rate of over 96%. They are also operating drone killer Biho-2. It says that the Patriot missile has replaced Shad. Korea's missile defense shield is world-class. Thank you for the broadcast that is concerned about Korea.

韩国不担心。韩国已经开发了自己的L-SAM防御系统。这种导弹比萨德更具精确性和射程。而且,阿联酋正在部署Cheongung-2,拦截率超过96%。他们还在操作无人机杀手Biho-2。说萨德已被爱国者导弹取代。韩国的导弹防御盾牌是世界一流的。感谢关心韩国的广播。

@xina***FreeT...t
The city of Seoul is within artillery range from the border of North Korea so why the hell would they use a missile to attack them?? Thaad is useless against low flying cruise missile because it is high altitude exo atmospheric defense

首尔市距离朝鲜边境的炮击范围内,那么为什么他们要用导弹来攻击首尔呢?萨德对低空巡航导弹无效,因为它是高空外大气层防御系统。

@snoreberry1786
The US can freely redeploy their assets as needed. That is why they are mobile. S. Korea is free to buy their own if they don't want it moved.

美国可以根据需要自由重新部署他们的资产。这就是他们的机动性。如果韩国不想让它被移走,他们也可以自己购买。

@jazleen5743
so were now calling middle east ,west asia suddenly? lol

所以现在我们突然把中东称为西亚了吗?哈哈。

@RedEyeFish1
N Korea needs to improve its drone technology of all kinds instead of navy ships and subs that will be destroy by American technology but with drone is cheap and in huge volumes and easy to launch it cannot be totally destroy by anyone....

朝鲜需要改善各种类型的无人机技术,而不是依赖海军舰艇和潜艇,因为这些很容易被美国的技术摧毁,但无人机便宜、数量庞大且易于发射,任何人都不可能完全摧毁它们……

@snoop_doggy-v2u
Kim is crazy for receiving a toy for global destruction. The man is sick!!! He doesn't understand that once the missile alx is sent, all the missiles will be aimed at dozens of countries, each facing their bitter rivals.

金正恩为了得到一个用于全球毁灭的玩具而发疯了。这个人有病!!!他不明白,一旦导弹警报发出,所有导弹将瞄准几十个国家,每个国家都面临自己最强的对手。

@LisaRudolfs
What has South Korea been doing ? South Korea shouldn’t even be worried about THAAD , it should have its own and be able to take North Korea head on !

韩国在做什么?韩国根本不应该担心萨德,应该拥有自己的防御系统,能够直接面对朝鲜!

@johnsmalley6483
South Korea should never need to rely on the American government for defense. (They only have the American military help with defense until the South Korea can defend itself.

韩国永远不应该依赖美国政府来提供防御。(他们只是依赖美国军事帮助防御,直到韩国能够独立防御自己。)

@Aheadoftheherd
So maybe this is the plan, how about Japan's thaad and patriots are they moved too? Then that's when north and China will strike

所以也许这就是计划,日本的萨德和爱国者系统也被移走了吗?那时朝鲜和中国就会出手了。

@themossworld966
South Korea can not withstand North Korea. All allies to the US are exposed. Now I can imagine what data C is collecting. This is the same US that was claiming can defend Taiwan against C.

韩国无法抵挡朝鲜。所有美国的盟友都暴露在外。现在我可以想象C正在收集什么数据。这就是那个声称可以保护台湾(地区)免受C侵害的美国。

@YJ-bm7om
American are not a friend.south should be friend to there blood brother.

美国人不是朋友,韩国应该与他们的血脉兄弟做朋友。

 
相关推荐译文
中国已经垄断了94%的超大型油轮市场……韩国造船在高附加值船舶领域也遭遇惨败
中国教授精准预测伊朗战局,预言美国将落败
美国因"情报过时"意外轰炸伊朗学校
美国是否正在输掉与伊朗的战争?
美国为何向103个国家出售武器?
中国是否已经超越美国?马尼什·乔卡尼对市场和地缘政治的洞察
美军或将韩国防空系统转移至中东,以应对伊朗的报复行动
数十年未尝败绩,却遭友军背后捅刀 一周内 5 架美国战斗机被击落为哪般?